The Financial Reporting Council has this morning released its final 15
recommendations for increasing audit choice in the market.
The exercise follows over a year’s deliberation, open consultation and a
whittling down of hundreds of suggestions by the Market Participants Group.
The group was voted in last year in an effort to come up with solutions that
would be market-led.
Convenor of the MPG, and FRC chief executive, Paul Boyle said: ‘Our
consultation with stakeholders during 2006 revealed a preference for market-led,
rather than regulatory, actions to address the risks arising from concentration
in the audit market. The Group’s recommendations have the potential, over time,
to reduce the barriers to market efficiency. The effectiveness of the Group’s
recommendations will be determined principally by the choices made by companies,
investors and audit firms.
‘The FRC is grateful to the members of the Market Participants Group who have
worked constructively to develop these recommendations. We are also grateful to
the individuals and organisations who submitted responses to the Group’s
The MPG’s final recommendations:
1. The FRC should promote wider understanding of the possible effects on
audit choice of changes to audit firm ownership rules, subject to there being
sufficient safeguards to protect auditor independence and audit quality.
2. Audit firms should disclose the financial results of their work on
statutory audits and directly related services on a comparable basis.
3. In developing and implementing policy on auditor liability arrangements,
regulators and legislators should seek to promote audit choice, subject to the
overriding need to protect audit quality.
4. Regulatory organisations should encourage participation on
standard-setting bodies and committees by appropriate individuals from different
sizes of audit firms.
5. The FRC should continue its efforts to promote understanding of audit
quality and the firms and the FRC should promote greater transparency of the
capabilities of individual firms.
6. The accounting profession should establish mechanisms to improve access by
the incoming auditor to information relevant to the audit held by the outgoing
7. The FRC should provide independent guidance for audit committees and other
market participants on considerations relevant to the use of firms from more
than one audit network.
13. Regulators should develop protocols for a more consistent response to
audit firm issues based on their seriousness.
14. Every firm that audits public interest entities should comply with the
provisions of a Combined Code-style best practice corporate governance guide or
give a considered explanation.
15. Major public interest entities should consider the need to include the
risk of the withdrawal of their auditor from the market in their risk evaluation
Simon Wright of CareersinAudit.com discusses how an effective cyber defence force is critical to businesses worldwide and how internal auditors can make the transition to a new career in cyber security
The FRC has said that the investigation will 'consider, but not be restricted to, issues regarding misstated accounting balances'
Craig Maxwell joins the audit and assurance team in Scotland
Stephen Grayson to join the audit department in Manchester