PracticeAccounting FirmsLeader: Audit ‘baby steps’ are pragmatic

Leader: Audit 'baby steps' are pragmatic

Competition Commission takes a realistic, but relatively unexciting, view on opening up the audit market

THOSE WANTING audit market revolution are likely to be disappointed.

The Competition Commission today says that the market isn’t working well, and changes are required. However, no-one would say that it’s proposals are anything more than relatively gentle – direct and disruptive intervention it ain’t.

The arguments for evolution rather than revolution are strong. Grant Thornton and BDO wouldn’t really want audit work and tendering foisted upon them. They want the channels to market opened up, not made more onerous.

The commission is right to call for investors to step up to the plate. It is imperative that they get more involved in the audit process, rather than continue with this strange abdication of responsibility that sees management effectively pick and choose their auditor. Investor activism has certainly made boards sit up and take note in recent years – but it would be nice for the investment community to be more proactive, as opposed to indignant reaction.

While the commission is seemingly less concerned about the proliferation of ex-Big Four in regulatory roles, what must be highlighted is the seemingly unbreakable circle of Big Four partners moving into FD roles, who are subsequently very ‘comfortable’ having a Big Four firm in as auditor. But this is a chicken and egg situation – non-Big Four firms picking up bigger audits would see boards more comfortable picking non-Big Four accountants into top finance roles.

Another hurdle to overcome is that of making audit more forward-facing. This will inevitably involve more audit work to be undertaken, and greater risk of litigation. Such a move seems more likely to block entrants into the market.

But ultimately the commission is right – it will take a series of measures that help to change buying behaviour, and it won’t happen overnight.

Kevin Reed is editor of Accountancy Age and Financial Director

Related Articles

Top 50+50: Firms fall short on diversity

Accounting Firms Top 50+50: Firms fall short on diversity

2m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
BDO's 'agility' makes it well placed to succeed - Eagland

Accounting Firms BDO's 'agility' makes it well placed to succeed - Eagland

1y Kevin Reed, Writer
Friday Afternoon Live: Discussing the aims and intent of Connolly-driven CogitalGroup

Accounting Firms Friday Afternoon Live: Discussing the aims and intent of Connolly-driven CogitalGroup

1y Kevin Reed, Writer
How accountancy firms are responding to Brexit

Accounting Firms How accountancy firms are responding to Brexit

1y Michelle Pery
PwC expands return to work scheme

Accounting Firms PwC expands return to work scheme

1y Richard Crump, Writer
Leader: Why Connolly's new venture is unlikely to chase Big Four; or follow failed consolidator model

Accounting Firms Leader: Why Connolly's new venture is unlikely to chase Big Four; or follow failed consolidator model

1y Kevin Reed, Writer
Former Deloitte boss and HgCapital launch CogitalGroup

Accounting Firms Former Deloitte boss and HgCapital launch CogitalGroup

1y Richard Crump, Writer
Former Deloitte boss John Connolly plots 'rival' to Big Four

Accounting Firms Former Deloitte boss John Connolly plots 'rival' to Big Four

1y Richard Crump, Writer