THE PAC has now concluded its session with the heads of tax from PwC, Deloitte, KPMG and Ernst & Young with, I suspect, little change in the opinions from either side. Having watched the questioning, I was impressed by the heads of tax.
Unsurprisingly, they are bright, mentally alert people with a strong client service ethos and a desire to abide by the law. They were, I have to say, very well prepared and were robust in expressing their opinions and prepared to defend their tax practices.
I think the issue has been triggered by the fact that the government is short of funds and wants to increase the tax take. Its problem is that the length and complexity of UK law (to which it is contributing) means that there is a huge grey area of tax planning/avoidance that falls between sensible avoidance e.g. ISAs and evasion. However “morally repugnant” the planning in the middle ground may be, it is legal; firms have a duty to advise clients and directors have a duty to shareholders. In all of this, tax mitigation is a legitimate part of maximising returns.
HMRC has the right to challenge planning. It is advised on schemes and people using them have to notify; it can challenge on connected party transactions and will soon be able to use the General Anti-Abuse Provisions as well as the existing targeted anti-avoidance legislation.
Just a thought, but perhaps the government should invest a bit more in HMRC, rather than decrying the fact that accountants employ a lot of intelligent people. It could, of course, also seek to simplify the legislation so there is less room for debate. Neither seems likely to happen, so I am not sure where we go next.
I suspect that, in reality, each taxpayer will continue to decide where the boundaries are and act accordingly.
Cathy Corns is a corporate tax partner at Mercer & Hole
This article originally appeared on Mercer & Hole’s blog
Companies must report on their complex financial structures including offshore accounts and notify HMRC
An examination by the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) has revealed serious concerns relating to HMRC’s plans
The mornings after the night that was the British Accountancy Awards; and Andrew Tyrie's latest thoughts on Making Tax Digital timing
Andrew Tyrie suggests there will not be enough time to implement Making Tax Digital (MTD) by April 2018