TaxCorporate TaxLeader: Tax arguments crystallised, but debate continues

Leader: Tax arguments crystallised, but debate continues

Accountancy Age's tax avoidance debate proves a success: with the various arguments around the issue aired and documented. But the arguments continue..

Leader: Tax arguments crystallised, but debate continues

This article originally appeared in the Accountancy Age tax avoidance Debate

IT’S BEEN AN eventful, thought-provoking and interactive week of debate.

But we have a ‘winner’. BDO’s Stephen Herring has pipped Richard Murphy in the voting stakes.

Such a close call demonstrates what a difficult issue tax avoidance is to compartmentalise. There will be many, myself included, whose opinions sit somewhere between those of Richard and Stephen.

The ‘grey area’ inevitably leads to each situation being dealt with as the facts and context are combined – but case-by-case is unsatisfying and uncertain.

Take the Goldman Sachs bonus deferral row. The government’s intention is to lower the rate of the higher tax band. MPs criticised the bank for considering pushing back bonus payments so they fall in the new ‘lower’ high rate. But deferring payments could have been easily forseen and legislated against. By not dealing with that, can we say that giving bonus payers the opportunity to shift payments was, or wasn’t, the intention of parliament?

It’s not exactly a case of the bank setting up an exotic scheme involving subsidiaries and sending funds on a circuit. But in the context of being viewed as nasty ‘take take take’ bankers, GS decided against the move. Instinctively, it feels they made the right ‘choice’.

The tax avoidance issue will rumble on. But our debate has proved that both ‘sides’ have compelling and popular viewpoints, and the issue requires cool, logical and reasoned thinking, rather than knee-jerk political point-scoring.

Click here to view the whole debate

Kevin Reed is editor of Accountancy Age

Related Articles

Big names, little tax: Airbnb, Facebook, Kellogg’s, eBay

Corporate Tax Big names, little tax: Airbnb, Facebook, Kellogg’s, eBay

1m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
EU divided over radical tax reforms targeting tech giants

Corporate Tax EU divided over radical tax reforms targeting tech giants

2m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
How to educate your clients about tax avoidance

Corporate Tax How to educate your clients about tax avoidance

2m Clear Books | Sponsored
Colin: Tell them about the money, mummy

Business Regulation Colin: Tell them about the money, mummy

1y Taking Stock
Five key tax and business burdens the chancellor must ease in Autumn Statement

Business Regulation Five key tax and business burdens the chancellor must ease in Autumn Statement

1y Kevin Reed, Writer
CGT clampdown nets HMRC £124m – but could lead to increase in use of avoidance schemes

Corporate Tax CGT clampdown nets HMRC £124m – but could lead to increase in use of avoidance schemes

2m Austin Clark, Reporter
‘Google tax’ nets HMRC £281m

Corporate Tax ‘Google tax’ nets HMRC £281m

2m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Autumn Statement: Investment and tax avoidance highlighted in Hammond's speech

Corporate Tax Autumn Statement: Investment and tax avoidance highlighted in Hammond's speech

12m Kevin Reed, Writer