PracticeAccounting FirmsWatering down women on boards quota is not the way to go

Watering down women on boards quota is not the way to go

The revised European Commission quota to increase the number of women on boards is a missed opportunity, writes Fiona Hotston Moore

Watering down women on boards quota is not the way to go

THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION recently approved proposals from justice commissioner Viviane Reding to have women in at least 40% of board positions by 2020. Unfortunately, following fierce opposition from a number of member states, including the UK, the proposals have been watered down and will not address the unconscious and political bias which blocks the progress of a pool of talented and aspiring senior women executives.

The proposals approved by the European Commission will require member states to put in place measures designed to ensure women hold 40% of non-executive board positions by 2020. These apply only to large listed companies and the proposal is for a common objective, rather than prescriptive regulations and sanctions.

In my view, this is an opportunity missed to address the discrimination inherent in our boards and the appointments process by implementing temporary compulsory gender quotas. Self-regulation has not worked and the current proposals allow member states and their large corporates to continue to pay lip service to the proven business case for diversity on boards.

Since the Davies Report (which proposed the board quotas) was issued in February last year, we have indeed seen an increase in women in non-executive roles, up from 15% to 22% in the FTSE 250. But in executive roles, the gender balance has barely moved from 5%. With the recent resignations of Pearson boss Dame Marjorie Scardino and Cynthia Carroll from Angle America, we are left with just two women holding the top job in the FTSE 100.

The fortunate few women who have made it to the pinnacle often argue against quotas because they encourage tokenism. But in fact, quotas correct existing discrimination. Quotas are the most effective tool to challenge inertia and to force the break-up of elite “clubs”.

The head of a large executive board search agency admitted to me recently that he only put one woman forward out of hundreds of applicants for a post, and seemed proud of the fact. Are we seriously supposed to believe that the rest were all deluded or hopelessly unqualified?

Norway imposed quotas in 2006 and now all companies have one woman on the board and over 80% have more than three women.

I do not accept that we don’t have a pool of suitable candidates. I meet a lot of very talented women who are ready for board positions and frustrated by the attitudes of chairs and board search agencies who refuse to take them seriously.

Diverse boards have been shown to increase shareholder value and to reduce corporate risk. Diverse boards have better understanding of their teams, customers and local business culture. They are more creative and less likely to follow group think. I have not heard anyone suggesting we should not be pushing for diversity on boards, but the question is how we challenge the status quo.

Whilst I am disappointed by the watering down of the EU proposals, I am delighted by the amount of debate the topic of quotas has generated and I hope this means both governments and large corporates are finally starting to engage in the discussion.

I hope that by the time my daughter joins the workforce in 2020 we will finally appoint board members based on merit, rather than gender, school or background.

Fiona Hotston Moore is a partner at Reeves

Related Articles

Top 50+50: Big Four hold steady, shake-up outside Top 20

Accounting Firms Top 50+50: Big Four hold steady, shake-up outside Top 20

3w Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Top 50+50: Revenue rises spark rankings shake-up

Accounting Firms Top 50+50: Revenue rises spark rankings shake-up

3w Emma Smith, Managing Editor
New boss and office on the south coast for Smith & Williamson

Accounting Firms New boss and office on the south coast for Smith & Williamson

12m Kevin Reed, Writer
Jeffreys Henry promotes Justin Randall to managing partner

Accounting Firms Jeffreys Henry promotes Justin Randall to managing partner

1y Richard Crump, Writer
UHY Hacker Young appoints new partner in London Office

Accounting Firms UHY Hacker Young appoints new partner in London Office

1y Richard Crump, Writer
Wilkins Kennedy joins Allinial Global but reaffirms IAPA relationship

Accounting Firms Wilkins Kennedy joins Allinial Global but reaffirms IAPA relationship

1y Stephanie Wix, Writer
Friday Afternoon Live: Xero's 'code of conduct'; British Accountancy Awards; and Top 50+50

Accounting Firms Friday Afternoon Live: Xero's 'code of conduct'; British Accountancy Awards; and Top 50+50

1y Kevin Reed, Writer
Cowgill Holloway concludes sale of film distributor Metrodome

Accounting Firms Cowgill Holloway concludes sale of film distributor Metrodome

1y Richard Crump, Writer