Brexit & EconomyPoliticsHodge’s horse trading really makes no sense

Hodge's horse trading really makes no sense

Industry minister Margaret Hodge seems adamant

She is standing by plans to introduce a new offence of ‘knowingly or
recklessly’ signing off misleading company accounts. It is a step that makes
auditors nervous. The battle to have the key paragraph changed in the company
law reform bill has rumbled through the Lords and now it is in the Commons.

Hodge seems unconcerned. She warned that this was the quid pro quo for
allowing auditors to negotiate proportionate liabilities. But MPs are already
warning the minister to think long and hard about the inclusion of the new
penalty. They would prefer alternative words such as ‘dishonestly or
fraudulently’.

The interesting thing about this measure is Hodge’s assertion that it is a
proposal that balances the concession of having proportionate liability. This is
an odd bit of horse trading and makes for poor policy making. Surely the way you
make law is to consider a proposal on its own merits. In this instance
government appears to have created an artificial attachment between liability
and reckless auditors.

Was it necessary? Accountants in the Commons appear to imply that something
is needed by asking for a compromise on the wording. But Hodge’s statement seems
to point to a political deal. You can only have proportionate liability if you
let us throw some auditors in prison. Or to put it another way, you can’t have
something unless we take something too, or it won’t look good.

If pro auditor MPs are to head this off, they will have a fight on their
hands. Whereas debate in the Lords was measured there are those in the Commons
who will make sure that there is plenty of scare mongering around UK audit. The
argument is now set for its climactic final stages.

Related Articles

5 key takeaways from Theresa May’s Florence speech

Brexit 5 key takeaways from Theresa May’s Florence speech

3m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
UK at risk of Brexit talent brain-drain

People Practice UK at risk of Brexit talent brain-drain

4m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Brexit essentials: this week's round-up

Politics Brexit essentials: this week's round-up

4m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Government publishes post-Brexit customs arrangements policy paper

Politics Government publishes post-Brexit customs arrangements policy paper

4m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Italy grants first successful non-dom status application to former UK non-dom

Personal Tax Italy grants first successful non-dom status application to former UK non-dom

4m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Increased government spending partly offset by high tax revenue

Governance Increased government spending partly offset by high tax revenue

5m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Less than a third of UK businesses have made formal Brexit plans

Politics Less than a third of UK businesses have made formal Brexit plans

5m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Nicky Morgan elected Chair of the Treasury Committee

Politics Nicky Morgan elected Chair of the Treasury Committee

5m Alia Shoaib, Reporter