BusinessCompany NewsDon’t shoot the auditor

Don’t shoot the auditor

Few would suggest that everything is perfect in UK auditing. Firms make mistakes, auditors miss things

Companies collapse, and there are no major firms in the UK whose records are
unblemished on this issue. But suggestions that somehow UK auditing is rotten
because another company has gone bust are wide of the mark.

The latest case is Farepak, the Christmas hamper company. Ernst & Young
is the auditor in question, and the accusation at the weekend was that one
should not bother waking the auditors – ‘they’re asleep’. Well, not quite.

Some of the comment about Farepak seems ill-informed. Just because a company
lends money to another company in the group does not mean you qualify the
group’s audit, for instance. Whether or not E&Y should have seen the
company’s collapse coming is more of a moot point.

But there is a broader point here. Firms routinely draw attention to problems
in corporate reporting for which they attract little or no attention. Auditors
will, behind the scenes, spot problems that never make a public appearance.

When firms do intervene in such ways, there is little fanfare. Questions are
not asked in parliament, and leader writers do not bend over backwards to
congratulate the engagement partner on his or her work.

Audits are a complicated business, involving careful judgments about
intricate issues. Reading a business’s prospects is complicated. The question
may be that if auditors are not required to see such problems coming, perhaps
it’s the system that needs addressing.

But anyone who wants to hang the audit industry on the evidence of nothing
more than a corporate collapse and an unqualified audit should be prepared for
disappointment. It is easy to make accusations about firms. But, as Equitable
Life found with Ernst & Young, it is quite another proving them.

Related Articles

BDO replaces Deloitte as Mitie auditor

Audit BDO replaces Deloitte as Mitie auditor

3m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
CVR Global appoints partner in London office

Company News CVR Global appoints partner in London office

7m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
FTSE100 failing to provide adequate ethics information

Company News FTSE100 failing to provide adequate ethics information

7m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Moore Stephens recruits new private client partner

Accounting Firms Moore Stephens recruits new private client partner

10m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Magma Group announces merger, partner promotions

Accounting Firms Magma Group announces merger, partner promotions

10m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
BDO on ‘recruitment spree’ with multiple partner appointments

Accounting Firms BDO on ‘recruitment spree’ with multiple partner appointments

10m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Brand strength leads to fee income growth for RSM

Accounting Firms Brand strength leads to fee income growth for RSM

10m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Mazars strengthens audit team with partner appointment

Accounting Firms Mazars strengthens audit team with partner appointment

10m Emma Smith, Managing Editor