More NewsAccountancy Age Leader

Accountancy Age Leader

Why look for solutions, if there isn't a problem

‘We found no compelling need to take action.’ Those are the words of the US
Government Accountability Office (GAO) after looking into audit choice in the
US.

The report, out last week, concluded that in the absence of ‘limited
evidence’ the current concentrated audit market has had no adverse impact and
that there is a ‘general lack’ of any decent suggestions to put things right.
The problem with the GAO’s report lies in those arguments. First it says there’s
no problem, but then there is an underlying admission that there is, by saying
that no solutions could be found. No solution is needed if there is no problem.

The GAO must know there is a problem because the public companies is surveyed
told it so. Around 60% said there was no adequate choice among large audit
firms. Respondents also declared that the disappearance of a large firm would
reduce choice and possibly increase audit fees.

Despite these poignant pieces of evidence, the GAO concluded that, because
there is no proof of reduced choice pushing up fees or proof of a fall in audit
quality, nothing needs to be done. Readers would be excused for finding the
GAO’s report contradictory and short-sighted.

Quite rightly, the UK has concluded there is an issue to be resolved, the
question here was how best to deal with it. Fortunately for the US, the GAO’s
report will not be the last word on the matter. Former SEC chief Arthur Levitt
is heading a special committee examining audit choice for the US Treasury.

Interestingly, the GAO may have given this group a lead by identifying access
to capital and difficult state law as hindrances to building another large firm.
We can only wait to see what Levitt and his fellow members on the advisory
committee will make of them.
comment@accountancyage.com

Related Articles

Amazon UK halves its corporation tax bill despite increased turnover

More News Amazon UK halves its corporation tax bill despite increased turnover

4m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Increase in UK business confidence despite Brexit, according to ICAEW

More News Increase in UK business confidence despite Brexit, according to ICAEW

7m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Live blog: Spring Budget 2017

Corporate Tax Live blog: Spring Budget 2017

9m Accountancy Age editorial
The Curious Incident of the Insolvency Sector in the Light of Economic Turbulence

Insolvency The Curious Incident of the Insolvency Sector in the Light of Economic Turbulence

11m Accountancy Age editorial
Leonard Curtis called in as administrators for builders Boshers

Legal Leonard Curtis called in as administrators for builders Boshers

11m Stephanie Wix, Writer
New Year Honours of 2017

Accounting Standards New Year Honours of 2017

11m Stephanie Wix, Writer
"Not enough time" to implement MTD by 2018, says Tyrie

Corporate Tax "Not enough time" to implement MTD by 2018, says Tyrie

1y Stephanie Wix, Writer
Colin: A spoonful of investment...

Governance Colin: A spoonful of investment...

1y Stephanie Wix, Writer