Tweedie: Audit reports “hopeless”

Tweedie: Audit reports "hopeless"

ICAS's president says the audit report fails to deliver value and transparency for investors

AUDIT REPORTS have been described as “hopeless” by ICAS president Sir David Tweedie.

Sir David, who became one of the most globally-recognised accountants after running the UK and then international standard setters, said during an online discussion that the report fails to show the auditor’s opinion, reports The Herald.

“The audit report at present is hopeless. It’s full of who is repsonsible for what, and it’s difficult to find the auditor’s opinion,” he stated.

Sir David wants more information presented to investors about the contentious policies used by companies, and information on going concern assumptions.

It is not the first time that Sir David has spoken out for more value to be gleaned from the audit report. In January he said that moves by the international audit standard setters (IAASB) to make the audit a more vital part of investment analysis would serve to highlight “good” audit work by the accountants.

“Everyone knows a bad audit – now that it’s splattered all over the pages of the press as a company gets into serious trouble, undetected by the auditor,” he added. “But no one knows when there has been a good or outstanding audit.”

Related Articles

Bruce Cartwright, Incoming CEO, ICAS

People In Business Bruce Cartwright, Incoming CEO, ICAS

5m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Financial Power List 2018: 21-25 revealed

People In Business Financial Power List 2018: 21-25 revealed

5m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Anton Colella, CEO, Moore Stephens International (current ICAS CEO)

People In Practice Anton Colella, CEO, Moore Stephens International (current ICAS CEO)

5m Lucy Skoulding, Reporter
ICAS appoints former PwC partner as new CEO

Institutes ICAS appoints former PwC partner as new CEO

6m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Ex-ICAS president Jim Pettigrew appointed chair of Scottish Financial Enterprise

Accounting Standards Ex-ICAS president Jim Pettigrew appointed chair of Scottish Financial Enterprise

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
AAYP 2016: Five key skills auditors will need in the future

Accounting Standards AAYP 2016: Five key skills auditors will need in the future

2y Acccountancy Age
ICAS names Ken McHattie as new president

Accounting Standards ICAS names Ken McHattie as new president

2y Richard Crump, Writer
Former ICAS president to lead new ethics drive

Accounting Standards Former ICAS president to lead new ethics drive

3y Richard Crump, Writer