TaxCorporate TaxBudget 2013: GAAR a ‘deterrent’, with £235m haul estimate

Budget 2013: GAAR a 'deterrent', with £235m haul estimate

The GAAR won't bring in billions of pounds, but it is already working as a deterrent, says Bill Dodwell

CREATING a general anti-avoidance rule to act as a deterrent, rather than creating a mass caseload to deal with, seems to be borne out by the latest Budget figures.

The general anti-abuse rule, which will come into force this summer, will see a £235m haul between 2104 and 2018. But its impact on deterring avoidance, while no doubt higher, is impossible to quantify, according to Deloitte tax policy head Bill Dodwell.

“You can’t work out an absolute saving, for a deterrent,” said Dodwell.

Its enactment into law through the 2013 Finance Bill intends to clamp down on tax schemes that are abusive yet difficult to specifically legislate against.

An advisory panel, which includes Dodwell, has been put together to review schemes and determine whether they are contrived. The panel does not include HMRC representation.

Related Articles

‘Draconian’ GAAR penalties could breach human rights, taxation group warns

Accounting Standards ‘Draconian’ GAAR penalties could breach human rights, taxation group warns

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
Interview: GAAR is ready for action, panel chairman Mears says

Corporate Tax Interview: GAAR is ready for action, panel chairman Mears says

3y Calum Fuller, Reporter
GAAR chairman ‘doesn’t expect’ cases before 2016

Corporate Tax GAAR chairman ‘doesn’t expect’ cases before 2016

3y Calum Fuller, Reporter
GAAR panel chair should be allowed to choose own people

Corporate Tax GAAR panel chair should be allowed to choose own people

4y Calum Fuller, Reporter
PAC member Mitchell to assemble group to apply for GAAR panel posts

Corporate Tax PAC member Mitchell to assemble group to apply for GAAR panel posts

4y Calum Fuller, Reporter
GAAR advisory panel seeks National Insurance expertise

Corporate Tax GAAR advisory panel seeks National Insurance expertise

3y Calum Fuller, Reporter
GAAR panel member steps down after Panorama sting

Corporate Tax GAAR panel member steps down after Panorama sting

4y Calum Fuller, Reporter
HMRC budget cut 5% in Spending Review

Corporate Tax HMRC budget cut 5% in Spending Review

4y Rachael Singh, Writer