TaxCorporate TaxCharge for GAAR clearance system, Lords told

Charge for GAAR clearance system, Lords told

Members of the House of Lords Economics and Finance Bill 2013 sub-committee continued their analysis of how successful the GAAR is likely to be

ANY CLEARANCE SYSTEM for the general anti-abuse rule (GAAR) should be paid for by those running the tax schemes going through it, members of the House of Lords Economics and Finance Bill 2013 Sub-Committee were told.

A clearance system would allow for a broader scope than the rule – which will come into force over the summer once it receives royal assent – is currently designed to have.

Evidence was provided to the committee by CIoT president Patrick Stevens, institute colleague Bill Dodwell and Tax Research UK founder Richard Murphy.

Murphy, the keenest proponent of such a clearance system, told lords that charging would cover the cost for HM Revenue & Customs officers to analyse the schemes.

Dodwell, though, warned that doing so may divert HMRC staff from other, more important, activities.

The committee had previously convened on Monday, with the original author of the GAAR recommendations, Graham Aaronson QC, warning the rule would not act as a cure-all against tax abuse, and should be treated instead as an additional weapon in HMRC’s arsenal.

Other tax regimes and competition make it “inevitable companies will locate activities in countries which suit them best”, he said.

Those sentiments were echoed by Murphy and Stevens, who warned the rule would not stop multinationals using transfer pricing – the intra-company trade of goods and rights across international borders – to ensure their affairs are tax-efficient.

The government’s enquiries into tax avoidance will continue on 31 January, when the Public Accounts Committee will hear from representatives of the Big Four.

Related Articles

Markets expected to respond positively to US policy changes

Corporate Tax Markets expected to respond positively to US policy changes

7m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
UK has ‘vital role to play’ in beating tax evasion, declares Panama Papers whistleblower

Corporate Tax UK has ‘vital role to play’ in beating tax evasion, declares Panama Papers whistleblower

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
An 'incomprehensible and contradictory' Budget

Accounting Firms An 'incomprehensible and contradictory' Budget

2y Richard Crump, Writer
House of Lords slams ‘inadequate’ HMRC in Finance Bill inquiry

Corporate Tax House of Lords slams ‘inadequate’ HMRC in Finance Bill inquiry

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
‘Draconian’ GAAR penalties could breach human rights, taxation group warns

Accounting Standards ‘Draconian’ GAAR penalties could breach human rights, taxation group warns

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
MPs launch inquiry into UK corporate tax system

Corporate Tax MPs launch inquiry into UK corporate tax system

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
Treasury Select Committee to lead review of UK tax system

Corporate Tax Treasury Select Committee to lead review of UK tax system

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
Parliament to debate digital tax accounts this month

Administration Parliament to debate digital tax accounts this month

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter