TaxCorporate TaxGAAR not panacea, Aaronson tells Lords

GAAR not panacea, Aaronson tells Lords

Graham Aaronson QC, author of the original anti-tax avoidance recommendations, and Malcolm Gammie QC warn Lords that the incoming rule will not be a cure-all

THE INCOMING General Anti-Abuse Rule will not act as a cure-all in preventing all forms of tax avoidance, members of the House of Lords sub-committee on the 2013 Finance Bill heard.

The rule, which will be included in the Bill, will not be implemented until it receives royal assent in July, rather than April as originally expected.

Graham Aaronson QC, author of the original GAAR recommendations, and Malcolm Gammie QC, leader of the GAAR study group, told committee members the rule will be “one weapon among many available to HM Revenue & Customs to tackle avoidance”, adding it “must be seen in that context”.

They added that while the legislation could “in theory” be used to “explore stopping multinationals’ tax avoidance”, it is unlikely to do so in practice.

Other tax regimes and competition make it “inevitable companies will locate activities in countries which suit them best”, they said.

On the implementation of an advisory panel to determine which tax arrangements fall within the rule’s scope, Aaronson admitted he is “agnostic” on the idea of a Revenue figure’s inclusion, but understood the desire of many that the panel remain independent.

He added that guidance notes, produced by HMRC and approved by the panel, will form detailed criteria by which the panel will determine whether a scheme is egregious. Those notes, however, will not be scheduled into the legislation in order to prevent the need to update them in successive Finance Bills. Instead, the advisory panel will continually update the guidance, with the notes enshrined in the legislation.

The sub-committee will re-convene tomorrow (23 January) with further discussions on tax avoidance due to take place. Tax Research UK founder Richard Murphy – who last week took part in Accountancy Age’s debate on tax avoidance – and CIoT president Patrick Stevens will provide evidence.

Related Articles

Big names, little tax: Airbnb, Facebook, Kellogg’s, eBay

Corporate Tax Big names, little tax: Airbnb, Facebook, Kellogg’s, eBay

1m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
EU divided over radical tax reforms targeting tech giants

Corporate Tax EU divided over radical tax reforms targeting tech giants

2m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
How to educate your clients about tax avoidance

Corporate Tax How to educate your clients about tax avoidance

2m Clear Books | Sponsored
Autumn Statement: Investment and tax avoidance highlighted in Hammond's speech

Corporate Tax Autumn Statement: Investment and tax avoidance highlighted in Hammond's speech

1y Kevin Reed, Writer
Colin: Tell them about the money, mummy

Business Regulation Colin: Tell them about the money, mummy

1y Taking Stock
CGT clampdown nets HMRC £124m – but could lead to increase in use of avoidance schemes

Corporate Tax CGT clampdown nets HMRC £124m – but could lead to increase in use of avoidance schemes

2m Austin Clark, Reporter
‘Google tax’ nets HMRC £281m

Corporate Tax ‘Google tax’ nets HMRC £281m

2m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Markets expected to respond positively to US policy changes

Corporate Tax Markets expected to respond positively to US policy changes

6m Alia Shoaib, Reporter