PracticePeople In PracticeDeloitte student fabricated doctor’s letter to retake exams

Deloitte student fabricated doctor's letter to retake exams

ICAEW tribunal finds dishonesty of "the most severe kind" as student creates doctor's letter to stay with Deloitte

A DELOITTE STUDENT fabricated a letter in an attempt to persuade his employer to allow him to retake his accountancy exams, an ICAEW tribunal has found.

Having twice failed an ICAEW exam, and set to have his contract with Deloitte terminated, Nahied Kabir produced a doctor’s letter to support his case for a third attempt. This was accepted, and Kabir passed.

However, he then failed a further three exams, producing a letter regarding his mother’s health in mitigation. However, this second letter was nearly identical to the first, though he claimed that her condition was similar to his. Deloitte terminated his employment.

Kabir told the tribunal that Deloitte had lacked understanding about his mother’s condition and failed to give him sufficient support.

With Kabir admitting the creation of the false document, the tribunal fined him £1,000 and declared him unfit to be an ICAEW member.

It said his dishonesty was of “the most severe kind”.

“The tribunal was unimpressed by the defendant attempting in his communication with the institute dated 4 August 2011 to criticise his employer and imply that somehow they were to blame for his actions,” the tribunal stated. “The tribunal was also unimpressed by the defendant’s use of his mother’s ill health as the reason to obtain advantage for himself.”

Related Articles

Paul Aplin, Incoming President, ICAEW

People In Business Paul Aplin, Incoming President, ICAEW

4m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Financial Power List 2018: 11-15 revealed

People In Business Financial Power List 2018: 11-15 revealed

4m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Michael Izza, CEO, ICAEW

People In Business Michael Izza, CEO, ICAEW

4m Lucy Skoulding, Reporter
Financial Power List 2018: 36-40 revealed

People In Business Financial Power List 2018: 36-40 revealed

4m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Taking Stock: PwC outdoes ICAEW in the nibble stakes (steaks)

Accounting Standards Taking Stock: PwC outdoes ICAEW in the nibble stakes (steaks)

2y Taking Stock
ICAEW president: We must adapt to add to our heritage

Accounting Standards ICAEW president: We must adapt to add to our heritage

2y Richard Crump, Writer
ICAEW appoints new executive for professional standards

Accounting Standards ICAEW appoints new executive for professional standards

2y Richard Crump, Writer
AAYP 2016: The 35 under 35

Accounting Firms AAYP 2016: The 35 under 35

2y Richard Crump, Writer