PracticeAccounting FirmsConstruction firm sues Menzies over tax advice

Construction firm sues Menzies over tax advice

Menzies to "vigorously defend" itself against claim from clients of tax return mistakes

THE OWNERS of a construction business have launched a legal battle for compensation from accountants Menzies.

Company directors Hugh and Susan Kitchin, their son Alexander, and Brian Doolan are demanding damages of more than £168,000 from the Farnborough based firm.

They are joined in their claim by construction company HA & DB Kitchin, the partnership HA & BD Kitchin, and Will Hall Properties (Alton) Ltd.

Menzies produced accounts and tax returns for the company between 2003 and 2008, when property developer Mr Kitchin senior brought in accountants Wilkins Kennedy instead, according to a High Court claim.

The directors and businesses accuse Menzies of making mistakes over their tax returns, leading to repayment by HMRC of more than £35,000 to Hugh Kitchin and £3,000 to Alexander Kitchin in 2009.

They say Menzies misdeclared VAT, which meant Will Hall had to pay a penalty of £1,548 in 2009.

They accuse Menzies of breach of contract and negligence, and say the firm failed to advise how their liabilities could be minimised, and failed to calculate accurately the level of the partnership debt.

A Menzies spokesman said: “Having examined details of the allegation carefully, we believe this claim to be unfounded and intend to vigorously defend our work.”

One transaction in 2003 was described as £240,732 when it should have been £470,006 while another in 2005 was described as £7,094 when it should have been £499,071, the claim alleges.

Mr and Mrs Kitchin, Mr Kitchin, and Mr Doolan, all of The Old Manor, Newton Valance, Alton, Hampshire, and their businesses, all of The Barn, Will Hall Farm, Basingstoke Road, Bolton, Hampshire, say their losses total £168,156.50.

Their claim was issued by Ian Lakin of solicitors Cavendish Lakin.

Related Articles

Top 50+50: Big Four hold steady, shake-up outside Top 20

Accounting Firms Top 50+50: Big Four hold steady, shake-up outside Top 20

2m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Top 50+50: Revenue rises spark rankings shake-up

Accounting Firms Top 50+50: Revenue rises spark rankings shake-up

2m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
New boss and office on the south coast for Smith & Williamson

Accounting Firms New boss and office on the south coast for Smith & Williamson

1y Kevin Reed, Writer
Wilkins Kennedy joins Allinial Global but reaffirms IAPA relationship

Accounting Firms Wilkins Kennedy joins Allinial Global but reaffirms IAPA relationship

1y Stephanie Wix, Writer
Friday Afternoon Live: Xero's 'code of conduct'; British Accountancy Awards; and Top 50+50

Accounting Firms Friday Afternoon Live: Xero's 'code of conduct'; British Accountancy Awards; and Top 50+50

1y Kevin Reed, Writer
Cowgill Holloway concludes sale of film distributor Metrodome

Accounting Firms Cowgill Holloway concludes sale of film distributor Metrodome

1y Richard Crump, Writer
Jeffreys Henry promotes Justin Randall to managing partner

Accounting Firms Jeffreys Henry promotes Justin Randall to managing partner

1y Richard Crump, Writer
UHY Hacker Young appoints new partner in London Office

Accounting Firms UHY Hacker Young appoints new partner in London Office

1y Richard Crump, Writer