RegulationCorporate GovernancePractitioner reprimanded for conflict of interest

Practitioner reprimanded for conflict of interest

ICAEW insolvency practitioner severely reprimanded for asking directors to award themselves a bonus so they could pay him

Practitioner reprimanded for conflict of interest

AN INSOLVENCY PRACTITIONER has been severely reprimanded and fined by the ICAEW for a conflict of interest.

Eric Stonham, of Chichester, was fined £5,000 and ordered to pay £7,000 costs after asking directors of a company of which he was administrator to award themselves a bonus fee which would then pay his pre-appointment fees.

Stonham had acted for two directors of struggling R-Bar & Restaurant Limited prior to his appointment as administrator, and was due a fee of £2,000. Unable to pay him at the time, an agreement was reached where he would be paid when their personal finances improved.

Unable to claw back the fees when acting as administrator for the company, he suggested the directors award themselves a bonus from the company.

The tribunal decided that his suggestion was with the intention that the directors could use the bonus to pay him back. Stonham accepted that a part of his motivation must have been to increase the chances of his pre-appointment fees being paid.

“It appeared to [the tribunal] that Mr Stonham turned a blind eye to the ethics of his actions in the belief that he was entitled to be paid. His conduct however had been improper and brought discredit to the ICAEW, the profession and himself,” said the tribunal in its disciplinary orders statement.

Stonham had previously been fined and reprimanded for a conflict of interest-related issue, and was also issued a penalty for unauthorised remuneration.

Stonham’s counsel put forward mitigation, drawing attention to written testimonials.

Counsel pointed out there was no risk of repetition and no financial loss to anyone had occurred. His practice had made changes to “regularise” his documentation.

Related Articles

MPs hear from trio of Big Four firms over BHS advice

Accounting Firms MPs hear from trio of Big Four firms over BHS advice

1y Chris Warmoll, Writer
Law Society pours scorn on ICAEW's latest attempt to expand its legal reach

Accounting Standards Law Society pours scorn on ICAEW's latest attempt to expand its legal reach

1y Kevin Reed, Writer
Sun goes down on solar installer as 34 jobs lost in insolvency

Accounting Firms Sun goes down on solar installer as 34 jobs lost in insolvency

2y Chris Warmoll, Writer
UK governance rules in need of shake-up, say AA readers

Business Regulation UK governance rules in need of shake-up, say AA readers

3y Richard Crump, Writer
UHY Hacker Young fined over audit family tie

Accounting Standards UHY Hacker Young fined over audit family tie

3y Chris Warmoll, Writer
Boards must use ethics to drive value, say accountants

Corporate Governance Boards must use ethics to drive value, say accountants

2y Kevin Reed, Writer
Professionalism and 'success from the City' key for ICAEW and ICAS

Accounting Standards Professionalism and 'success from the City' key for ICAEW and ICAS

2y Chris Warmoll, Writer
USC administration to be investigated by the Insolvency Service

Accounting Firms USC administration to be investigated by the Insolvency Service

3y Kevin Reed, Writer