TaxCorporate TaxRank hits jackpot in European VAT ruling

Rank hits jackpot in European VAT ruling

ECJ ruling will lead to VAT refunds stretching back more than 30 years

THE GAMING industry received a boost as the Rank Group won its long-running dispute over the VAT treatment of gambling receipts.

The European Court of Justice found that HM Revenue & Customs breached the rule of fiscal neutrality by treating similar gaming machines in different ways for VAT purposes. Claims covering the period 2003 to 2005 have been paid, but this judgement will pave the way for hundreds of businesses to receive refunds from as far back as the 1970s.

Richard Wild, PKF’s director of VAT, said: “Although the case turned on some highly technical arguments, the basic position is that the taxman cannot treat two similar machines in a different way for VAT purposes, as this breaches the basic rule of fiscal neutrality, even if machines fall under different licensing categories, as they can in the UK.”

Anbreen Khan, VAT partner at Deloitte, who advised Rank, commented: “This is a fair decision, which corrects the unlawful application of VAT across the industry. We have always considered that there was a fiscal imbalance in the VAT treatment of certain gaming machines and forms of bingo. We are pleased that the ECJ has endorsed the previous rulings of the UK Courts that VAT was wrongly levied and should be repaid.”

HMRC argued that it acted with due diligence to ensure compliance with fiscal neutrality, but the ECJ said there was no defence of due diligence available under European law.

An HMRC spokesman said: ‘HMRC is studying the judgment and will issue further advice once the potential implications have been identified.

‘The ECJ decision simply answers the questions raised of it by the Court of Appeal and the Upper Tribunal and the case will need to return to the domestic courts for them to consider the position in light of the ECJ judgment.

‘The judgment clarifies how the principle of fiscal neutrality should be interpreted and sets out the test to be applied in determining the similarity or otherwise of gaming machines.’

Related Articles

'Innocent' companies will be hit by tough HMRC anti-fraud powers

Corporate Tax 'Innocent' companies will be hit by tough HMRC anti-fraud powers

1y Stephanie Wix, Writer
Building company director banned for 7 years for VAT under-declaration

Corporate Tax Building company director banned for 7 years for VAT under-declaration

1y Richard Crump, Writer
Berkshire motor business VAT fraudsters sentenced

Corporate Tax Berkshire motor business VAT fraudsters sentenced

1y Richard Crump, Writer
The growth and challenges of digital sales taxes globally

Corporate Tax The growth and challenges of digital sales taxes globally

1y Editorial comment
CIoT urges government to rethink VAT approach to online traders

Corporate Tax CIoT urges government to rethink VAT approach to online traders

1y Richard Crump, Writer
UK votes to leave EU – accountancy profession reacts

Accounting Firms UK votes to leave EU – accountancy profession reacts

1y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
HMRC calls for extra time in Spot the Ball legal battle

Corporate Tax HMRC calls for extra time in Spot the Ball legal battle

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
Bishop Fleming launches new cloud accounting product

Accounting Firms Bishop Fleming launches new cloud accounting product

2y Richard Crump, Writer