RegulationCorporate GovernanceNo distinction between accountants or solicitors on tax advice

No distinction between accountants or solicitors on tax advice

ICAEW argues in Prudential appeal that advice provided by accountants is the same as lawyers, and therefore accountants' clients should benefit from legal profesisonal privilege

There is no distinction between the advice accountants give out on tax
compared with lawyers, the ICAEW argued in court yesterday in its battle to win
professional privilege for tax advisers.

The ICAEW appeared before the Court of Appeal in the Prudential case
yesterday, where the insurer previously lost its argument against HM Revenue
& Customs that tax advice received from its accounting advisers should be
confidential under legal professional privilege, the same as solicitors.

Charles Flint QC, representing the ICAEW told the court you “can’t
distinguish between the two”.

“They are performing the same function in the same context,” argued Flint.

“Advice on tax is advice on law. What qualification gives accountants room to
advise on law? It’s the study of taxation. The institute has the overriding
interest of acting in the public interest.”

Flint said there was no ground for a distinction between the quality of
advice between that set in terms of training between chartered accountants and
lawyers.

The court will hear from the Law Society today, expected to argue that
privilege should be retained by the legal profession.

The hearing continues today.

Further reading:

Vital
“professional privilege for accountants” case back at High Court

Related Articles

Law Society pours scorn on ICAEW's latest attempt to expand its legal reach

Accounting Standards Law Society pours scorn on ICAEW's latest attempt to expand its legal reach

2y Kevin Reed, Writer
New HMRC exec chair outlines priorities to PAC

Administration New HMRC exec chair outlines priorities to PAC

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
Bolton in "critical financial position" as taxman petitions for winding up

Corporate Finance Bolton in "critical financial position" as taxman petitions for winding up

2y Kevin Reed, Writer
Boards must use ethics to drive value, say accountants

Corporate Governance Boards must use ethics to drive value, say accountants

2y Kevin Reed, Writer
Professionalism and 'success from the City' key for ICAEW and ICAS

Accounting Standards Professionalism and 'success from the City' key for ICAEW and ICAS

3y Chris Warmoll, Writer
UK governance rules in need of shake-up, say AA readers

Business Regulation UK governance rules in need of shake-up, say AA readers

3y Richard Crump, Writer
UHY Hacker Young fined over audit family tie

Accounting Standards UHY Hacker Young fined over audit family tie

3y Chris Warmoll, Writer
ICAEW: Government must sort out finances or threaten recovery

Accounting Standards ICAEW: Government must sort out finances or threaten recovery

3y Kevin Reed, Writer