PracticeAuditBanking reform report: “fundamental questions” about purpose of audit

Banking reform report: "fundamental questions" about purpose of audit

Future of Banking commissions wants auditors to take a more critical eye over the way banks account for assets and liabilities

There needs to be “fundamental questions” about the purpose of audit
following the financial crisis, called the UK commission into the future of
banking.

The Future of
Banking Commission
wants auditors to take a more critical eye over
the way banks account for assets and liabilities, looking beyond whether they
have stuck with the appropriate accounting rules, to gauge the underlying risk.

“The commission is concerned that auditors failed to report on the higher
levels of risk and leverage being run by the major banks,” stated the report.

It also called on a “robust classification criterion” for assets and
liabilities to ensure the numbers reported are meaningful and relevant.

“Regardless of the measurement basis, there is no substitute for the
professional judgment of the auditor,” it added.

The Financial Services Authority should also encourage more dialogue with
auditors, in order to flag up concerns about their clients and deal with any
risks before they grow out of control.

“It is important that early work is done to nip things in the bud, and
auditors are well placed to help in this activity.”

Tory MP David Davis, chair of the commission, said that “opaque accounting
practices” were, in part to blame for the crisis.

“The formalisation of international accounting rules had the perverse and
unintended effect of reducing the requirement on accountants to exercise
judgment in signing off balance sheets,” stated Davis in the report’s foreword.
“As a result, one of the historic checks on asset value was undermined.”

Further reading:

ICAS
urges Cable to throw SMEs a lifeline

Experts
reject fair value only methods

Candidates
in frame for top IASB role

Related Articles

Ukraine central bank removes PwC’s bank auditing rights

Audit Ukraine central bank removes PwC’s bank auditing rights

5m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
FRC confirms KPMG-HBOS report to be released ‘in spring’

Audit FRC confirms KPMG-HBOS report to be released ‘in spring’

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
Tyrie lays down gauntlet to FRC over HBOS probe

Audit Tyrie lays down gauntlet to FRC over HBOS probe

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
FRC considers plans to investigate KPMG over HBOS audit

Accounting Firms FRC considers plans to investigate KPMG over HBOS audit

2y Chris Warmoll, Writer
Tyrie "flabbergasted" by FRC failure to investigate HBOS audit failings

Accounting Firms Tyrie "flabbergasted" by FRC failure to investigate HBOS audit failings

2y Chris Warmoll, Writer
Tyrie reiterates call for FRC to probe KPMG over HBOS

Accounting Firms Tyrie reiterates call for FRC to probe KPMG over HBOS

2y Chris Warmoll, Writer
Extended auditor reports restoring trust in audit in post-HBOS world

Accounting Firms Extended auditor reports restoring trust in audit in post-HBOS world

2y Chris Warmoll, Writer
Has the value of audit to investors improved post-HBOS?

Audit Has the value of audit to investors improved post-HBOS?

2y Richard Crump, Writer