PracticeAuditEquitable Life: E&Y spared the worst

Equitable Life: E&Y spared the worst

Firms may struggle over how to disclose legal liabilities in the wake of the appeal ruling over Ernst & Young's audit of Equitable Life

The lasting legacy of Ernst & Young’s audit of Equitable Life may be
increased fees and lengthier audits as firms come to grips with when and how to
disclose legal liabilities.

The final chapter of the Equitable saga ended last week when an appeal ruling
was published on disciplinary charges brought against E&Y over the Equitable
audit. Costs and fines amounted to more than £9m in the original ruling.

he appeal reduced that to just under £3m and reversed a ruling that the firm
and auditor Kevin McNamara had sacrificed their objectivity and independence
during the audit.

The firm stumbled on a key accounting principle which governs how liabilities
arising from court cases are disclosed to shareholders.

In Equitable’s case, E&Y agreed it was very unlikely a key court case –
the Hyman case – would be lost and therefore no liability was recorded in the
Equitable accounts.

The case rested on E&Y accepting legal advice obtained by Equitable
instead of seeking further advice.

Under current accounting rules companies record a liability if the chances of
losing a court case, or having to pay out funds, is greater than 50%. The value
recorded in
the financial statements represents the company’s “best estimate” of this
liability.

Following last week’s verdict, industry figures close to the case believe
auditors may now second guess legal advice provided by their clients – a common
practice according to auditors and lawyers.

Seeking professional legal advice can be among the costliest exercises during
an audit. Seeking a second or third legal opinion from a reputable firm, some
feel, may considerably add to the cost of an audit.

One legal expert told Accountancy Age that such secondary advice would be
unnecessary in most cases.

There remains divergent approaches among corporations about how much
information to disclose about legal liabilities. Lawyers say while some firms
will disclose all information in the public domain, including information in
court documents and in the press, others will opt for a minimal approach.

A liability figure is only disclosed if there is a chance a company may have
to pay out at the end of a litigation. The amount is based on how much a
reasonable entity might pay to be rid of the liability.

Auditors agree on this figure in consultation with their client and sometimes
their client’s lawyers. A close observer of the Equitable tribunal said the
decision may add to the pressure in these circumstances to make the “right”
decision, despite the uncertainty and speculation which often surrounds major
court cases.

E&Y’s appeal was centred on the claim that the firm and its auditor
lacked objectivity and independence.

The appeal tribunal concluded: “In order to amount to a breach of the
fundamental principles of objectivity and independence something sigificantly
more serious is required than mere incompetence or inadvertence on the part of
the auditor in relation to specific audit issues.”

E&Y issued a statement which said: “We extend our sympathies to the
policy holders of Equitable Life, who have been impacted by the near collapse of
the society, following events which lay outside of our control and the remit of
our role as auditor.”

Further reading:

Equitable ruling leaves audit
guessing over legal liabilities

Related Articles

EY audit conflicts weigh on Royal Dutch Shell-BG Group deal

Audit EY audit conflicts weigh on Royal Dutch Shell-BG Group deal

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
Auditors face FTSE 350 concerns over cost of transition to new EU audit rules

Audit Auditors face FTSE 350 concerns over cost of transition to new EU audit rules

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
PwC to take on Weir Group audit

Accounting Firms PwC to take on Weir Group audit

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
‘Ten years’ to see fruits of mandatory rotation – Non-Big Four auditors

Audit ‘Ten years’ to see fruits of mandatory rotation – Non-Big Four auditors

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
Mandatory audit rotation 'further entrenches' Big Four

Audit Mandatory audit rotation 'further entrenches' Big Four

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
Stagecoach set for EY audit appointment

Audit Stagecoach set for EY audit appointment

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
EY extracts Vedanta Resource audit as Deloitte tenure ends

Accounting Firms EY extracts Vedanta Resource audit as Deloitte tenure ends

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
PwC appointed as auditor to probe Vatican finances

Accounting Firms PwC appointed as auditor to probe Vatican finances

2y Chris Warmoll, Writer