RegulationAccounting StandardsPlan to shed light on shadowy mining deals

Plan to shed light on shadowy mining deals

IASB proposals may shed light on shadowy deals between mining and oil companies and resource-rich nations

Global trade in “conflict diamonds” may seem a long way from accounting rule
making, however the two subjects converged last week with proposals which could
force mining and oil companies to reveal shadowy pay­ments to resource-rich
nations.

The International Account­ing Standards Board last week released a discussion
paper which could lead to a global set of accounting rules for mining and oil
companies.

Compiled by senior accountants in Australia, Canada, Norway and South Africa,
the paper explores whether extractive industries should adopt country-by-country
reporting. Under the proposals, mining and oil companies would report royalty,
tax, bonus and licence fee payments for each of their host nations.

The 184-page report represents the culmination of a long-running
international campaign to force companies to reveal how much they pay foreign
governments.

It followed a 1999 landmark report A Crude Awakening, by humanitarian group
Global Witness, which showed that wealth generated from oil and mining companies
in Angola helped fuel the nation’s civil war and prop up a corrupt
administration.

Following this study, a handful of UK-based humanitarian groups banded
together under the banner Publish What You Pay (PWYP) to campaign for greater
financial transparency from oil and mining companies.

Most multinational businesses aggregate their costs, which makes it near
impossible to define exactly how much they pay host nations.

PWYP, now a global operation, wants international accounting rules to be a
vehicle to force extractive industries to reveal how much they pay governments
around the world. The coalition was intimately involved in the production of the
discussion paper but last week said it was disappointed by the outcome.

The IASB, which must justify any new accounting rules by their relevancy to
the investor community, said there was some demand from investors for the added
information but said there is a risk the new measures will prove too costly and
complex.

“The project team notes that further study is required to conclude on whether
the country-by-country disclosure of payments to governments is justifiable on
cost-benefit grounds,” the report stated.

Vanessa Herringshaw, dir­ector of Revenue Watch and a member of PWYP,
dismissed these concerns and pointed out that some companies voluntarily publish
a limited form of country-by-country data.

“Companies have this information anyway,” she said. “They have to have it in
order to report their payments and revenue in countries…if they are claiming
they don’t have it one could question whether they have adequate management
information.”

Oil-field-quote

Bob Garnett, board member with the IASB, said there was a risk financial
reports would become too lengthy. “The trouble is that with most information, we
ask ‘would [investors] like more’ and the answer is always ‘yes’,” he said.

Before his appointment to the IASB Garnett worked with one of the world’s
largest mining companies, Anglo American plc, where he tried to avoid trading in
so-called conflict diamonds, which fuel civil war and corruption in developing
nations.

He dismissed concerns that the information would prove too difficult to
capture. “What we are looking for is anything that is controlled by state
officials…and collecting all of that data will take some time, but it can be
done,” he said.

By the end of 2010 a ­decision will be made on whether to add the PWYP
proposals to the official IASB agenda, a major step towards it becoming a global
standard. However any final standard could take years to create, approve and
finally be adopted.

Related Articles

IASB overhauls insurance accounting with issuance of IFRS 17

Accounting Standards IASB overhauls insurance accounting with issuance of IFRS 17

7m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Former CFO joins IASB board

Accounting Standards Former CFO joins IASB board

1y Stephanie Wix, Writer
MEP calls for IASB pay cuts

Accounting Standards MEP calls for IASB pay cuts

1y Richard Crump, Writer
IASB issues amendments to insurance contracts standard

Accounting Standards IASB issues amendments to insurance contracts standard

1y Richard Crump, Writer
IASB chairman Hoogervorst to prioritise communication effectiveness of financial statements during second term

Accounting Standards IASB chairman Hoogervorst to prioritise communication effectiveness of financial statements during second term

1y Richard Crump, Writer
IFRS Foundation to cut board size and improve transparency

Accounting Standards IFRS Foundation to cut board size and improve transparency

2y Richard Crump, Writer
Indonesia set to achieve full IFRS convergence

Accounting Standards Indonesia set to achieve full IFRS convergence

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
FASB publishes US leasing standard

Accounting Standards FASB publishes US leasing standard

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter