Allen Stanford may still be grabbing headlines as he awaits trial on charges
of fraud worth $8.5bn but it is forensic accountants who will play a prominent
role in readying the case for both sides and testifying as expert witnesses.
Forensic accountants’ involvement in American criminal and civil litigation
has become more visible because of the sensational nature of recent financial
scandals, according to 30-year industry veteran Ronald L. Durkin, senior
managing director of specialist accounting firm Durkin Forensic.
The biggest challenge is gathering records. “There are bound to be millions
of computer files and electronic documents that must be forensically preserved
and duplicated,” writes Robert Harris, vice chair of the American Institute of
Certified Public Accountants (AICPA).
In an October case hearing, the prosecution said it had established a
searchable computer database with 4.1 million records and that it expects to add
at least another 1.5 million documents.
Stanford and his co-defendants are charged with defrauding investors who
purchased around $7bn in certificates of deposit administered by Stanford
International Bank. The company allegedly misappropriated most of those assets,
including more than $1.6bn for personal loans to Stanford himself, according to
the government indictment.
An important strategy for forensic accountants is finding a benchmark period
where assets and liabilities were fairly stated. Financial statements are then
rolled forward on an account by account basis to see which assets dropped off
the balance sheet and what debt was added, said Durkin.
Insurance policies, depreciation schedules, tax returns and loan applications
are used to identify missing assets. Gathering these records is especially
challenging in an international case like Stanford’s, with the company’s
headquarters in Antigua, investors in more than 100 countries and branch offices
in the US and abroad.
“It’s a ripple effect. When the funds are moved from country to country, it
becomes quite a challenge to find the scent and follow the trail,” said Durkin,
who tracked the assets of Saudi billionaire arms dealer Adnan Khashoggi in the
late 1980s and 1990s.
“My guess is that there will be a considerable amount of records missing and
therefore forensic accountants will need to reconstruct the financial and
accounting transactions,” Durkin speculated. Once the story of the assets has
been reconstructed, forensic acc-ountants need to tell that story.
“Communication skills are important when appearing before a jury or a judge,”
Durkin, who honed his testimonial skills as a special agent for the FBI, added.
“You have to be able to take complicated, complex issues and put them in simple
terms that are easy to understand.”
Certification for forensic accountants isn’t required, though there are a
of certifications offered by various professional associations.
The biggest drawback for clients is cost. Upon suspicion of fraud, a company
retains a law firm and the firm hires a third party to conduct the forensic
accounting, so that the forensic accounting work will be protected by
“What most people don’t realise is that, once we find the fraud, like the
$50bn in the Madoff case, then the costs grow significantly due to the
tremendous expense of the lawyers and forensic accountants,” said Larry
Crumbley, professor of accounting at Louisiana State University.
Allen Stanford’s defence attorneys have said it may take a year to prepare
“A year is a lot of man hours and a lot of money,” Crumbley said.
IN OUR VIEW
When things go bad, forensic accountants often find themselves in demand
on both sides of a conflict. But it is a necessity if the wrongdoing of
fraudsters and other criminals is to be fully uncovered.
The second largest improvement in ‘significant’ levels of financial distress since the EU Referendum was in professional services, found research from Begbies Traynor
Two new audit partners have been appointed at the firm BDO in its audit practice following continued growth and investment
Investment in people, tech and businesses impacts on EY's profit per partner figure
If businesses do not take cyber security seriously in their business planning regulators may do it for them, the ICAEW has warned