Trial without jury dropped from Criminal Justice Act

Trial without jury dropped from Criminal Justice Act

Government trial scraps plans for without jury in serious fraud cases under Act, and now plans to introduce new legislation

The government has scrapped plans to use powers in the Criminal Justice Act
to facilitate trial without jury in serious fraud cases, and now plans to
introduce permissive provisions in new legislation.

The move was announced in the Lords by Attorney-General Lord Goldsmith, who
said it had proved impossible to negotiate a compromise solution with opposition
parties to abolish the right to trial by jury using order-making powers under
the act.
He said ministers now plan primary legislation to push the proposal through.

Goldsmith rejected a bid by Liberal Democrat Lord Thomas of Gresford, a
former deputy High Court judge, to strengthen the power of judges to control
cases and speed up trials, including instead the curtailment of lengthy
cross-examinations.

A series of peers, including former Law Lords and a former Tory attorney
general insisted judges and prosecutors were to blame for celebrated fraud cases
that had collapsed, and insisted that if cases were presented properly, juries
could cope.

Thomas said the opposition ‘cannot agree that it is necessary or desirable to
abolish juries in complex cases’.

Earlier during debates on the fraud bill, Goldsmith rejected proposal to
scrap the crime of ‘conspiracy to defraud’ following the creation of the
statutory offence of fraud and with it the narrower statutory offence of
‘conspiracy’.

He introduced a new clause making it an offence to defraud a machine – to
catch those committing internet and chip-and-pin card crimes.

Related Articles

Financial Secretary to the Treasury on cryptocurrency, Brexit and taxing the digital economy

Brexit Financial Secretary to the Treasury on cryptocurrency, Brexit and taxing the digital economy

3m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
HMRC’s refusal to raid top Tory donor Lycamobile to be investigated by MPs

Big Four HMRC’s refusal to raid top Tory donor Lycamobile to be investigated by MPs

3m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Spring Statement 2018: Spring has sprung as chancellor finds his inner Tigger

Budget Spring Statement 2018: Spring has sprung as chancellor finds his inner Tigger

4m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Spring Statement live feed

Budget Spring Statement live feed

4m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Spring Statement 2018: 5 things to look out for

Brexit & Economy Spring Statement 2018: 5 things to look out for

4m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Financial Secretary to the Treasury on Brexit, Spring Statement, Making Tax Digital and Carillion

Politics Financial Secretary to the Treasury on Brexit, Spring Statement, Making Tax Digital and Carillion

6m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
David Davis, Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union

Brexit & Economy David Davis, Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union

6m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Philip Hammond, Chancellor of the Exchequer

Brexit & Economy Philip Hammond, Chancellor of the Exchequer

6m Alia Shoaib, Reporter