PracticeAuditAudit inspection unit defends its ‘consistent approach’

Audit inspection unit defends its ‘consistent approach’

Audit Inspection Unit director dismisses E&Y's suggestions that audit reports of leading firms should be clearer

ernst and young building

The director of the
Audit Inspection
Unit
has dismissed suggestions from
Ernst
& Young
that the reports on audit services of leading firms should be
improved and made clearer.

The AIU published its in-depth reviews on the seven biggest UK firms for the
first time this week.

The AIU, part of the
Professional Oversight
Board
within the Financial
Reporting Council
, said that the audit firms’ practices were generally
acceptable, but the reports also highlighted a series of flaws.

In its response to the review, E&Y said that it hoped the criteria on
which auditors are judged in public reports would ‘develop over time’. It said
it would ‘continue to work closely’ with the AIU.

AIU director Andrew Jones said most of the feedback from firms reviewed had
been positive, adding: ‘We do develop the work we undertake and our processes
each year but we are consistent in our approach between firms’

In the report on Ernst & Young ,the AIU said that its audit services were
‘generally good or acceptable’ but added that there was room for improvement in
areas including the independence of some non-audit services and risk assessment.

The AIU criticised a number of E&Y audits for failing to show enough
evidence that it was
meeting standards on independence of audit and advice services.

‘We considered there was insufficient evidence on file for one of the audits
we reviewed to demonstrate that proper consideration had been given to the
possible threats to the firm’s independence and objectivity arising from a tax
audit partner who also provided tax advice to his audit client,’ it said.

Related Articles

EY audit conflicts weigh on Royal Dutch Shell-BG Group deal

Audit EY audit conflicts weigh on Royal Dutch Shell-BG Group deal

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
Auditors face FTSE 350 concerns over cost of transition to new EU audit rules

Audit Auditors face FTSE 350 concerns over cost of transition to new EU audit rules

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
PwC to take on Weir Group audit

Accounting Firms PwC to take on Weir Group audit

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
‘Ten years’ to see fruits of mandatory rotation – Non-Big Four auditors

Audit ‘Ten years’ to see fruits of mandatory rotation – Non-Big Four auditors

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
Mandatory audit rotation 'further entrenches' Big Four

Audit Mandatory audit rotation 'further entrenches' Big Four

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
Stagecoach set for EY audit appointment

Audit Stagecoach set for EY audit appointment

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
EY extracts Vedanta Resource audit as Deloitte tenure ends

Accounting Firms EY extracts Vedanta Resource audit as Deloitte tenure ends

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
PwC appointed as auditor to probe Vatican finances

Accounting Firms PwC appointed as auditor to probe Vatican finances

2y Chris Warmoll, Writer