Tory Treasury spokeswoman Baroness Sheila Noakes has attacked the Financial
Reporting Council’s plans to amend guidance meant to help audit committees look
beyond the Big Four when choosing auditors.
‘They’re trying to find solutions in a way that does not affect the
underlying problems, which is that there are four large firms and everyone would
like there to be more,’ said Baroness Noakes, who is also a senior FTSE audit
The FRC wants to amend the Smith Guidance, which was drawn up in 2003, to
assist directors serving on audit committees in carrying out their role. The
changes stem from the recommendations made by the Market Participants’ Group,
which was tasked with finding solutions to limited audit choice in the UK.
One of the FRC’s recommendations called for audit committees to regularly
assess the risk of their auditor leaving the market and put contingency plans in
But Baroness Noakes said this would do little to improve auditor choice, as
large companies would be forced to tender the audit to one of the other giant
She also criticised the suggestion that audit committees should tell
shareholders why they have recommended the appointment, re-appointment or
removal of an auditor.
Baroness Noakes said this created ‘artificial pressures for tenders’ that
would be ‘dangerous and costly for firms and fantastically time consuming for
FRC chief Paul Boyle said there were some cases in which companies could not
use an alternative Big Four source for an audit because they had already given
these firms other work.
‘It could breach independence rules. Committees might like to think about
whether they have left themselves a real choice in the event of their existing
auditor withdrawing from the market,’ he said. He added that the FRC did not
suggest more frequent tendering of contracts.
MHA MacIntyre Hudson has partnered with cloud accounting software provider Xero ahead of the government’s requirement for digital records
Smaller businesses could be excluded from government plans for making business transactions digital, found new research from ICAEW
The second largest improvement in ‘significant’ levels of financial distress since the EU Referendum was in professional services, found research from Begbies Traynor
Further powers are being sought by HMRC, but it is ‘failing’ to use those it already has, such as Conduct Notices, says RPC