BusinessBusiness RecoveryRevenue drops Exeter FC challenge

Revenue drops Exeter FC challenge

The Inland Revenue has backed out of its challenge to Exeter City FC's Company Voluntary Arrangement (CVA), just days after a similar challenge against Wimbledon FC ended in defeat in the Court of Appeal.

Link: ‘Pragmatic’ Revenue drops Wimbledon challenge

The taxman had been planning to argue that the CVA was unlawful because football ‘super creditors’ – as defined by the football conference – were to be paid in full, reducing the money it could recoup. But it appears to have thought again in light of its defeat in the Wimbledon case.

Sue Bunning, of Clarke Willmott, solicitor for Exeter, said: ‘I was quite surprised to get the call because the cases were quite different on the facts. This may help insolvency practitioners who can probably arrange CVAs now without fear of a Revenue challenge.’

But she warned that the great ‘super creditor’ debate could rumble on. ‘The issue is not going to go away because there are a fair number of professionals unhappy about it – mainly insolvency practitioners,’ she said.

Comment: The super creditor rule

Bunning said she believed the Revenue might still challenge CVAs where the alternative was less bleak than had been the case with Wimbledon and Exeter. Both clubs faced almost certain oblivion in the wake of a successful Revenue action.

With the hurdle of the taxman’s legal assault on its CVA removed, Exeter can now secure its survival as long as it keeps up its repayments. Some £400,000 is due within the next year and a half.

Earlier this year the club itself withdrew a planned action, this time against the football conference for ‘unfairly prejudicial treatment’ including the imposition of the super creditor rule.

Stephen Allinson, insolvency partner at Clarke Willmott, said: ‘The effect of the Revenue’s withdrawal means that the ‘football creditors’ rule that was at the heart of this challenge by the Revenue remains in existence unless and until a successful action is taken in the future – but that will not now involve Exeter City.’

The Revenue said it could neither comment nor confirm it had dropped the case, citing ‘confidentiality’.

Related Articles

Carillion CFO blew whistle over 'sloppy accounting' months before collapse

Business Recovery Carillion CFO blew whistle over 'sloppy accounting' months before collapse

3m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Toys R Us UK and Maplin enter into administration after failing to secure buyers

Business Recovery Toys R Us UK and Maplin enter into administration after failing to secure buyers

3m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
How to avoid a Carillion collapse

Business Recovery How to avoid a Carillion collapse

4m Russell-Cooke
Carillion collapse: The week so far and industry reaction

Business Recovery Carillion collapse: The week so far and industry reaction

4m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Kingston Smith & Partners appointed trustees in bankruptcy of ex-Newcastle United footballer

Business Recovery Kingston Smith & Partners appointed trustees in bankruptcy of ex-Newcastle United footballer

4m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Carillion: PwC appointed as special managers – what happens now?

Business Recovery Carillion: PwC appointed as special managers – what happens now?

4m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Investment firm acquires Avon Steel Company Limited

Business Recovery Investment firm acquires Avon Steel Company Limited

6m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Manchester law firm enters into administration

Business Recovery Manchester law firm enters into administration

6m Emma Smith, Managing Editor