PracticeAccounting FirmsEquitable case is ‘rankest hypocrisy’

Equitable case is 'rankest hypocrisy'

E&Y QC says new Equitable management accepted E&Y's GAR figures.

Equitable Life’s new management and auditors PwC accepted Ernst & Young’s advice on GAR provisioning at the same time as they said it was negligent, a court has heard.

Link: E&Y to begin defence in Equitable case

Opening Ernst & Young’s defence against a £2bn claim against it from Equitable Life, Jonathan Gaisman QC pointed to documents that he said demonstrated ‘the rankest hypocrisy’.

In 2002, he said, not only did Charles Thomson, Equitable’s current chief executive, sign off accounts with a £200m provision for Guaranteed Annuity Rates (GAR), he also signed off a claim against E&Y saying that E&Y should have told it to provide for a greater provision and was negligent in not doing so.

The issue of the GAR provision is at the heart of Equitable’s case. It claims that E&Y should have told it to provide for more than that figure in 1999, and that its failure to do so has made it more than £2bn worse off.

Gaisman pointed to documents, however, showing the Thomson and PwC both accepted the £200m figure in several sets of accounts.

Not only that, but on April 15th 2002, it released its annual report and accounts which included the figure as an acceptable way of provisioning for GARs. On the same day, Thomson, in conjunction with PwC, signed a claim against its former auditors, E&Y, saying that E&Y should have warned it the figure was inaccurate.

If E&Y’s provisioning was so self-evidently wrong, Gaisman said, PwC and Thomson should have picked it up themselves in the 2001 Annual Report. Gaisman said: ‘the bringing of this claim represents the rankest hypocrisy’.

Related Articles

Sexual harassment – is accountancy next for #MeToo?

Accounting Firms Sexual harassment – is accountancy next for #MeToo?

7h Karen Baxter, Lewis Silkin
Johnston Carmichael CEO appointed as ICAS president

Accounting Firms Johnston Carmichael CEO appointed as ICAS president

3w Emma Smith, Managing Editor
British Accountancy Awards 2018 – entries open!

Accounting Firms British Accountancy Awards 2018 – entries open!

1m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Is the accountancy sector facing an international talent crisis?

Accounting Firms Is the accountancy sector facing an international talent crisis?

1m Lewis Silkin
RSM appoints new Chief Operating Officer

Accounting Firms RSM appoints new Chief Operating Officer

1m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
RSM announces 11 partner promotions

Accounting Firms RSM announces 11 partner promotions

2m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
BDO hires former AstraZeneca creative director as head of digital and innovation

Accounting Firms BDO hires former AstraZeneca creative director as head of digital and innovation

2m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
What does the future hold for listed accountancy firms?

Accounting Firms What does the future hold for listed accountancy firms?

2m Fergus Payne, Lewis Silkin