TaxCorporate TaxDixons contravenes transfer pricing rules

Dixons contravenes transfer pricing rules

Tax tribunal publishes decision

DSG International (Dixons) has been told it was in breach of transfer pricing
guidelines, however, a settlement is yet to be agreed upon between the retailer
and HM Revenue and Customs.

Observers believe DSG could end up owing the taxman hundreds of millions of
pounds.

In a 62 page document, special tax commissioners John Avery Jones and Charles
Hellier outlined the decision, which has centred on the insurance of extended
warranties and whether business facilities provided were set according to a
standard market rate.

Transfer pricing relates to the value placed on assets or goods moved
internally from one subsidiary to another within a multinational, and most often
across international borders.

HMRC pursues cases where it believes the price has been set artificially low
for tax purposes.

According to Steve Hasson, transfer pricing partner at
PricewaterhouseCoopers, the DSG decision has done little to resolve concerns
around the treatment of transfer pricing disputes.

‘While it’s interesting and illustrates once again the hazards of tax
litigation, it doesn’t give us a great deal of insight into how the courts
perceive transfer pricing,’ he said.

The case was heard before the Special Commissioners in London between 24
November and 12 December last year, but the decision is understood to have been
deferred for the two parties to reach a settlement figure through arbitration.

In the decision, the Special Commissioners agreed that DSG set prices on its
assets that ‘confers a potential advantage in relation to United Kingdom
taxation’.

Jonathan Peacock QC and Francis Fitzpatrick, counsel, instructed by Reynolds
Porter Chamberlain, acted for DSG International and David Goy QC, Michael Green
QC and Rupert Allen, counsel, were instructed by the General Counsel and
solicitor for HMRC.

Further Reading:

Accountancy
Age TV: Transfer pricing clampdown

Arbitration
not litigation will solve transfer pricing wrangles

Number
of transfer pricing enquiries to rise

Related Articles

Government deliberates secondary adjustment to transfer pricing rules

Administration Government deliberates secondary adjustment to transfer pricing rules

1y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
Accountants to play key role in new BEPS rules: OECD chiefs

Corporate Governance Accountants to play key role in new BEPS rules: OECD chiefs

2y Keith Nuthall, Reporter
Countries take cross-border tax lead, despite OECD plans

Corporate Tax Countries take cross-border tax lead, despite OECD plans

3y Kevin Reed, Writer
No unitary taxation “any time soon”, Lords told

Corporate Tax No unitary taxation “any time soon”, Lords told

4y Calum Fuller, Reporter
FTSE 100 companies criticised over use of tax havens

Corporate Tax FTSE 100 companies criticised over use of tax havens

5y Calum Fuller, Reporter
Thomson Reuters releases transfer pricing database

Corporate Tax Thomson Reuters releases transfer pricing database

4y Calum Fuller, Reporter
OECD to unveil business tax avoidance action plan to G20

Corporate Tax OECD to unveil business tax avoidance action plan to G20

4y Calum Fuller, Reporter
Transfer Pricing - A Necessary Evil?

Corporate Governance Transfer Pricing - A Necessary Evil?

4y Will James