TechnologyAccounting SoftwareProfession split over audit threshold

Profession split over audit threshold

Radical plans to raise the audit threshold to £4.2m are like ‘trying to solve all our social problems by abolishing the motorway speed limit,’ General Practitioners Board chairman John Malthouse said last week.

Speaking at an English ICA debate on the proposal, he said the plan was ‘cosmetic, irrelevant and dangerous’ and argued it would be the ‘outlaws’ that opted out of compulsory audits. He also questioned how accountants could advise clients without knowing they were using correct figures.

The DTI has delayed the publication of its consultation paper until September.

The debate showed that the proposal has divided the profession. Many agreed the government was using the issue as a ‘cheap shot’ to counter criticism about over-regulation.

But Baker Tilly’s Teresa Graham, of the Better Regulation Task Force, spoke in favour of the move. ‘We should not succumb to the tyranny of the status quo,’ she said.

She said entrepreneurs were ‘not stupid’. They could be convinced of the value of audit and would undertake them voluntarily to prove their viability to third parties, particularly finance providers, she argued.

The 120 delegates were also split. As debate opened up to the floor, sole practitioner John Harris described compulsory audit as a ‘protection racket’.

He added: ‘Let’s focus on selling something we can do well.’

But Eddie Weiss, of the 100 Group of FDs, said: ‘Most users of accounts feel reassured by audited accounts.’

See also, Letters

Related Articles

5 key tech innovations helping accountants transform their businesses

Accounting Software 5 key tech innovations helping accountants transform their businesses

3w Heather Darnell, Founder of Ask the BOSS
Finance and the tech foundation: what’s needed to deliver impactful business insights?

Accounting Software Finance and the tech foundation: what’s needed to deliver impactful business insights?

3m Workday | Sponsored
Best accounting software for businesses in the UK

Accounting Software Best accounting software for businesses in the UK

4m Accountancy Age, Reporters
Making sense of enterprise tech concepts for finance teams

Accounting Software Making sense of enterprise tech concepts for finance teams

4m Workday | Sponsored
Open Banking: what you need to know

Accounting Software Open Banking: what you need to know

4m Edward Berks, Xero
Accountancy in the digital age: Flexibility, agility, efficiency

Accounting Software Accountancy in the digital age: Flexibility, agility, efficiency

6m Pegasus Software | Sponsored
Sage purchases Intacct in its largest ever acquisition

Accounting Software Sage purchases Intacct in its largest ever acquisition

10m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
5 tips for SMEs to protect cash flow

Accounting Software 5 tips for SMEs to protect cash flow

10m Alia Shoaib, Reporter