TaxAdministrationVodafone ruling prolongs CFC confusion

Vodafone ruling prolongs CFC confusion

The Court of Appeal's ruling against Vodafone in the firm's ongoing tax dispute with the taxman leaves a 'big unanswered question' about the tax rules for companies operating outside the UK

vodafone logo

An ongoing tax dispute between
Vodafone
and HM Revenue &
Customs
has done little to clarify the tax rules for companies operating
outside the UK, after the Court of Appeal last week overturned an earlier
decision by the High Court.

The Court of Appeal ruled against the mobile phone giant which argued that UK
rules on the taxation of profits of foreign subsidiaries ­ controlled foreign
companies ­ was incompatible with European Union law.

Vodafone provisioned £2.2bn in its 2008 accounts in the event that it has to
pay up.

The dispute centers on the payment of taxes on the company’s Luxembourg
subsidiary where Vodafone registered Mannesman, the German mobile giant it
acquired in 2000.

The case has also highlighted discrepancies in the application of
cross-border CFC rules.

A spokesman for Vodafone confirmed that the company will be appealing to the
House of Lords on the basis that it has been conducting ‘genuine economic
activity’ in its Luxembourg subsidiary.

‘It’s flip-flopping from the High Court’s decision of last July,’ he said.

According to Bill Dodwell, head of tax policy at Deloitte, there is currently
no precedent on such cases as similar disputes are yet to be litigated.

‘We’ve had no court of judgment on what genuine economic activity is, which
is why we’re all struggling. It’s the big unanswered question,’ he said.

Related Articles

LITRG urges government to consider tax changes in disability work plan

Administration LITRG urges government to consider tax changes in disability work plan

4d Lucy Skoulding, Reporter
HMRC issues updated Trusts Registration Service guidance

Administration HMRC issues updated Trusts Registration Service guidance

3w Emma Smith, Managing Editor
‘Significant recovery’ for HMRC customer service, claims boss Thompson

Administration ‘Significant recovery’ for HMRC customer service, claims boss Thompson

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
HRMC loses £653,000 tax battle following administration error

Administration HRMC loses £653,000 tax battle following administration error

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
Bid to cut VAT bill on wedding venue hire rejected by Tribunal

Administration Bid to cut VAT bill on wedding venue hire rejected by Tribunal

2y Richard Crump, Writer
HMRC high-value tax cases drop 15%

Accounting Firms HMRC high-value tax cases drop 15%

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
Government deliberates secondary adjustment to transfer pricing rules

Administration Government deliberates secondary adjustment to transfer pricing rules

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
HMRC taskforces raise £540m since launch

Administration HMRC taskforces raise £540m since launch

2y Richard Crump, Writer