RegulationAccounting StandardsCredit rating agency stands by ‘flawed’ pensions logic

Credit rating agency stands by 'flawed' pensions logic

Standard & Poors defends FRS17 standard

Leading credit rating agency Standard & Poors has come to the defence of
the Accounting Standards Board, after a report claimed the organisation used
‘flawed logic’ when drafting its new standard for pension deficits.

The report, compiled by SEI Investments and Cardiff Business School, said the
FRS17 standard had over-inflated pension liabilities to the extent that the
FTSE100 deficit of £37bn would be reduced to zero if the ASB implemented an
appropriate discount rate method.

However, Sue Harding, European chief accountant at Standard & Poors,
argued that the ASB had explained the reasons for the discounting method
specified in FRS17 and that it was up to the market to interpret the deficit
disclosures correctly.

‘The discount rate in FRS17 is nothing more than a financial assumption made
for the sake of consistency. The ASB had to make a cut so that there was a
common starting point for all companies and we understand that,’ Harding said.

The SEI report claimed that the discount rate prescribed by FRS17, linking
discounting to the yield of an AA-rated bond, was low and had led to an
over-estimation of pension deficits. Discount rates should instead be based on
individual companies’ weighted average cost of capital.

‘The logic of FRS17 falls apart by resting on a discount rate that is
arbitrary and does not take into account the market-determined cost of capital
for the sponsoring firm,’ said Andrew Slater, institutional strategy director at
SEI Investments Europe.

But Harding warned that using any single discount rate would deliver
difficulties, and that all pension deficit disclosure required further analysis.
‘FRS17 has been helpful, but investors need to dig in and look into the detail,’
she said.

Related Articles

Demystifying GDPR for accountants

Accounting Standards Demystifying GDPR for accountants

1w Ellen Temperton, Lewis Silkin
EY fined £1.8m over Tech Data audit

Accounting Standards EY fined £1.8m over Tech Data audit

2m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
The great professional services shake-up

Accounting Standards The great professional services shake-up

3m Fergus Payne, Lewis Silkin
What do clients actually want from an accountant?

Accounting Standards What do clients actually want from an accountant?

4m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Accountants shouldn’t neglect hybrid mismatch anti-avoidance rules

Accounting Standards Accountants shouldn’t neglect hybrid mismatch anti-avoidance rules

4m Alison Conley
Membership of the accountancy profession on the rise

Accounting Standards Membership of the accountancy profession on the rise

5m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
The real price of mates' rates in the provision of professional services

Accounting Standards The real price of mates' rates in the provision of professional services

5m DAC Beachcroft
IASB overhauls insurance accounting with issuance of IFRS 17

Accounting Standards IASB overhauls insurance accounting with issuance of IFRS 17

7m Alia Shoaib, Reporter