PracticeAuditFull Mayflower judgement out

Full Mayflower judgement out

Independent panel's findings slams expert witness of AIDB

The Accountancy Investigation and Discipline Board has finally published the
full
judgment
of the Mayflower public tribunal.

The Mayflower tribunal – in which the AIDB brought
complaints against company’s FD David Donnelly and PricewaterhouseCoopers for
falling short of accounting standards – was the first public tribunal held by
the industry disciplinary board.

The 247-page judgement, by an independent panel which made findings on the
case, slammed the expert evidence of industry author Emile Woolf.

The panel stated in its report that the best interests of the case were not
served by the AIDB calling Woolf as their expert ‘independent expert’ since he
had been closely involved in the investigation and advised the AIDB to separate
investigative and expert roles in future cases.

The panel also took opportunity in their report to criticise the fact that
Woolf had not been a finance director, and therefore his opinion of what a
reasonably competent FD would do in certain circumstances was of limited
assistance during the case.

Woolf was also criticised for presuming against the directors of Mayflower
and ignorance which neither he, nor AIDB executive counsel
Cameron Scott, investigated.

The panel further noted the plain errors in Woolf’s report, inaccuracies in
his verbal evidence and his failure to answer questions until directed by the
panel chairman, to do so.

The panel, however, accepted the evidence of other witnesses, provided by the
PwC.

But the firm’s case was not helped by the misuse of a company secretary, of
terms such as ‘assurances’ and ‘undertakings’.

However, the panel considered the firm’s witnesses to be ‘honest’.

Further reading:

Tories demand Mayflower judgment

AIDB criticised after defeat at public
tribunal

PwC cleared as FRC transparency questioned

Related Articles

Is predictive analytics the end of the annual audit?

Audit Is predictive analytics the end of the annual audit?

3d Martin Herron, MHA MacIntyre Hudson
Auditors ‘in the dock’ over Carillion as report calls for Big Four break-up

Audit Auditors ‘in the dock’ over Carillion as report calls for Big Four break-up

1w Emma Smith, Managing Editor
PCAOB sanctions former Deloitte Turkey CEOs over altered documents

Audit PCAOB sanctions former Deloitte Turkey CEOs over altered documents

2w Alia Shoaib, Reporter
KPMG South Africa to review past audit work amid fresh scandal

Audit KPMG South Africa to review past audit work amid fresh scandal

1m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
FRC introduces £10m sanctions for Big Four firms

Audit FRC introduces £10m sanctions for Big Four firms

1m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Ukraine’s PrivatBank files $3bn claim against PwC

Audit Ukraine’s PrivatBank files $3bn claim against PwC

2m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Grant Thornton to exit FTSE 350 audit market, citing Big Four dominance

Audit Grant Thornton to exit FTSE 350 audit market, citing Big Four dominance

2m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Big Four dominate FTSE 250 audit market in Q1 rankings

Audit Big Four dominate FTSE 250 audit market in Q1 rankings

3m Alia Shoaib, Reporter