US think tank the Centre for Audit Quality has urged Congress to abandon
efforts to suspend mark to market accounting as the proposal continues to play a
central role in rescue plans for the economy in Washington.
The Hank Paulson plan reiterates powers of the US financial watchdog to
suspend mark to market while an alternative rescue package from a Republican
minority group calls directly for suspension.
A CAQ letter addressed to members of Congress says: ‘The principles of mark
to market accounting are rooted in the fundamental virtue of transparency and
are central to informed market decisions and efficient allocation of capital.
‘In our view, investor confidence would be undermined by efforts designed to
mask the actual value of financial assets at a given point in time.’
CAQ insists that mark to market did not cause the crisis but contributed to
knowledge about its severity.
Yesterday, shadow Tory chancellor George Osborne called for the suspension of
mark to market for three months making him the latest politician to believe an
accounting standard is a contributing factor to the financial crisis.
Mark to market has, however, received much support from regulators around the
world. The politicisation of the requirement has gathered pace as business
leaders in ailing institutions have intensified their calls for a change to the
Currently both the US standard setter FASB, and its internantional
counterpart, the IASB, have projects underway reviewing fair value, though both
have stood by the valuation method emphatically so far.
However, expert observers believe the issue lays in disclosure and
consolidation of the balance sheet rather than valuation under fair value.
Colin responds to the call for 'Darwinism' in accountancy
Does Darwin's theory apply to taxation? Colin ponders...
Colin comments on the effect of Brexit on the influx of partners at KPMG
Colin provides insight into the Tesco and Unilever scandal over Marmite