Umbrella body under threat as ICAS denounces merger

Umbrella body under threat as ICAS denounces merger

ICAEW to review CCAB participation following anti-merger comments

The future of the UK accountancy profession’s umbrella body was under threat
this week, after ICAS was accused of using ‘spoiling tactics’ designed to derail
merger talks between CIPFA and the ICAEW.

Link:
CIMA outlines
merger demands

The ICAEW said it would ‘revisit’ its collaboration with the Scottish
institute through the Consultative Committee of Accountancy Bodies, in light of
comments made by ICAS chief executive Des Hudson.

Writing in this week’s Accountancy Age, Hudson said the planned
merger of ICAEW and CIPFA was based on ‘unproven beliefs’. He said that the
argument that ‘one monolithic institute’ would be a more effective lobbyist was
an ‘unconvincing’ one.

ICAEW chief executive Eric Anstee responded angrily, saying he may look to
‘realign’ the institute’s funding of the CCAB. As it has the largest membership,
the ICAEW is the biggest funder of the 21-year-old body. ‘If ICAS wants to have
an equal voice, it must have an equal share of the budget,’ said Anstee.

He warned that the institute’s senior members may also want to consider
withdrawing from the committee, which he conceded would leave ICAS ‘in
difficulty’. Anstee added: ‘We will revisit collaboration in future. We will
look after our own members and leave them to look after theirs.’

The CCAB has taken more of a backseat role in regulatory reform since the
formation of the Financial Reporting Council. But it is still influential,
particularly on accountants’ training and international matters.

ICAEW and CIPFA members will vote on the merger proposals in October, while
CIMA is in favour of joining ‘in principle’ at a later stage.

CIMA chief executive Charles Tilley said the management accountants’
institute was ‘a strong supporter and key member of CCAB’. He added: ‘We have a
policy at the moment I’m entirely happy with. How we move forward in the future
depends on the circumstances.’

CIPFA chief executive Steve Freer said the public sector body would push
ahead with consolidation. ‘We don’t have any intention of responding to spoiling
tactics that risk damaging CCAB and the profession long term.’

Related Articles

Five reasons why your IFRS 9 project may have already failed

Accounting Standards Five reasons why your IFRS 9 project may have already failed

1w Nitin Iyer, Director in Global Risk Practice, Finastra
Is it time for moratorium on board room positions for former partners?

Accounting Standards Is it time for moratorium on board room positions for former partners?

1m Gary Dixon, Association of Independent Non-Executive Directors
Lease accounting standards: are multinationals sitting on a ‘leaseberg’ of huge proportions?

Accounting Standards Lease accounting standards: are multinationals sitting on a ‘leaseberg’ of huge proportions?

6m Ross Chapman, Aptitude Software
Demystifying GDPR for accountants

Accounting Standards Demystifying GDPR for accountants

11m Ellen Temperton, Lewis Silkin
EY fined £1.8m over Tech Data audit

Accounting Standards EY fined £1.8m over Tech Data audit

1y Emma Smith, Managing Editor
The great professional services shake-up

Accounting Standards The great professional services shake-up

1y Fergus Payne, Lewis Silkin
What do clients actually want from an accountant?

Accounting Standards What do clients actually want from an accountant?

1y Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Accountants shouldn’t neglect hybrid mismatch anti-avoidance rules

Accounting Standards Accountants shouldn’t neglect hybrid mismatch anti-avoidance rules

1y Alison Conley