TechnologyAccounting SoftwareContractors win first IR35 battle

Contractors win first IR35 battle

The Professional Contractors Group today won the first round of its legal battle against the Inland Revenue over the controversial tax measure IR35.

The Professional Contractors Group (PCG) today won the first round of its legal battle against the Inland Revenue over the controversial tax measure IR35.

The news followed an anxious wait by the founders of personal service companies after a High Court judge yesterday decided to reserve judgement until today on whether or not IR35 should undergo a judicial review.

After hearing arguments put forward by Gerald Barling QC on behalf of the PCG and Richard Plender QC for the Inland Revenue, Justice Gibbs gave permission for review.

IR35 regulations, which came into force in April, remove many of the tax advantages previously held by contractors who operated through personal service companies. The court reconvened at 10.30 this morning and a judgement was given a few hours later.

The PCG argued that IR35 is unfair because it taxes one-person businesses more harshly than other organisations, which it believes amounts to ‘state aid’ for large IT contracting companies. It has also said IR35 discourages contractors from trading in the UK and that IR35 contravenes the Human Rights Act.

But the Inland Revenue claimed the legislation ensures everyone who meets the accepted definition of an employee pays tax on broadly the same basis.

It argued that about 90,000 people working through service companies would otherwise be correctly taxed as employees.

The Revenue claimed these workers earn on average £50,000 a year, and of that they pay an average of 21 per cent in tax and National Insurance Contributions, compared with the 35 per cent which an equivalent direct employee would pay.

Members of the PCG immediately claimed IR35 should be dropped.

Gareth Williams, chairman of the PCG, said: “IR35 should now be suspended until this issue is resolved, and we ask the government to consider very carefully whether it should waste more tax payers money defending the indefensible. The government should now come clean – admit it made a mistake with IR35, repeal it and enter into proper consultation with the industry.”

First published on accountancyage.com

Related Articles

Accountancy in the digital age: Flexibility, agility, efficiency

Accounting Software Accountancy in the digital age: Flexibility, agility, efficiency

2w Pegasus Software | Sponsored
Sage purchases Intacct in its largest ever acquisition

Accounting Software Sage purchases Intacct in its largest ever acquisition

5m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
5 tips for SMEs to protect cash flow

Accounting Software 5 tips for SMEs to protect cash flow

5m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
UK behind foreign markets in digital accounting, but gap is narrowing

Accounting Software UK behind foreign markets in digital accounting, but gap is narrowing

7m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
The rise of the progressive accountant

Accounting Software The rise of the progressive accountant

7m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Making Tax Digital: Revolution or revolt?

Accounting Software Making Tax Digital: Revolution or revolt?

8m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Making Tax Digital: Is HMRC’s recent system fault a cause for concern?

Accounting Software Making Tax Digital: Is HMRC’s recent system fault a cause for concern?

8m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Four reasons why SME owners should switch to cloud accounting

Accounting Software Four reasons why SME owners should switch to cloud accounting

9m Emma Smith, Managing Editor