PracticePeople In PracticeLeader – Who will tell the public?

Leader - Who will tell the public?

The public audit bodies are squabbling again. At issue this time is who should audit the new public service agreements which will govern relations between Whitehall departments and other bodies. Both the National Audit Office and the Audit Commission think they should do it. The truth is that neither body is really up to the job.

The NAO is trapped in the constitutional fiction that MPs can hold the government to account in parliament. Labour’s sledgehammer majority, like the Tories’ of a decade ago, and the power of the whips, means that parliament is a toothless watchdog. The public accounts committee, to which the NAO reports, jealously guards its crumb of independence, preventing the NAO from speaking out without its sanction. And the fact that all NAO reports need the prior approval of the departments they audit further reduces its bite.

In theory, the Audit Commission is even less accountable. Its audit reports go to councillors who rarely publish them and to NHS trust boards who are accountable to no one except the health secretary. Yet it is much more publicly accountable. Its performance indicators name and shame failing councils and it speaks out on the big issues.

Instead of jockeying for position, the NAO and the commission would do better to promote a debate about how public audit can make the government more accountable to the public it is supposed to serve.

Related Articles

Is inefficiency stealing your time and money?

Accounting Firms Is inefficiency stealing your time and money?

6m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
CIMA elects new president

Institutes CIMA elects new president

6m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Transparent currency trade: How to achieve costs visibility

Governance Transparent currency trade: How to achieve costs visibility

6m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Introduction to KPMG UK’s new leadership team

Accounting Firms Introduction to KPMG UK’s new leadership team

6m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
EY appoints head of UK Infrastructure Asset Intelligence practice

Accounting Firms EY appoints head of UK Infrastructure Asset Intelligence practice

8m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
FRP Advisory expands operation with new office, partner appointments

Accounting Firms FRP Advisory expands operation with new office, partner appointments

10m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Magma Group announces merger, partner promotions

Accounting Firms Magma Group announces merger, partner promotions

10m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
MHA MacIntyre Hudson advises on management buy-out

Accounting Firms MHA MacIntyre Hudson advises on management buy-out

10m Emma Smith, Managing Editor