PracticeAuditBodies warn against US-style internal control

Bodies warn against US-style internal control

Profession and industry responds to Turnbull guidance, with principles-based approach heralded as the way forward.

The first consultation phase of the review into Turnbull’s guidance on internal control has just concluded. Here are some of the views over what direction any revised recommendations should follow.

ACCA
‘Turnbull’s principles-based approach has been more successful than the prescriptive line we have seen from the US via Sarbanes-Oxley,’ said ACCA chief executive Allen Blewitt.

‘We believe that the FRC review must retain a broad spectrum of internal controls, as opposed to Sarbox’s sole focus on matters which affect external financial reporting. But boards must not become too risk-averse ? risk management should be about seizing opportunities presented by the unexpected, as well as managing the downside.’

Blewitt added that market pressure will deliver more meaningful disclosures on internal controls than the suggested assertions of effectiveness, with the soon-to-be-introduced operating and financial review suggested as the ideal place for such disclosure.

CIMA
Charles Tilley, chief executive at CIMA, said that ‘the current approach of a high-level principles and risk-based approach is the correct one’ and that the report ‘should cover all controls, not just the financial ones’, but that there were several ‘practical issues’ surrounding public reporting of the controls.

ICAEW
Sir Hugh Collum, chairman of the Institute’s corporate governance committee, argued that should the board’s private assessment be made public; ‘there would inevitably be calls for this to be audited, leading to substantial additional costs’. It could also undermine the trust that underpins the capital market system, he said.

Sir Hugh thought that the current Turnbull guidance’s principles-based approach had been largely successful, leading to more meaningful and thorough consideration of risk at the board level.

He said the ICAEW would also resist any move to limit the scope of focus to just financial controls as this ‘would not take into account the full diversity of risks companies face’.

ABI
A submission from the Association of British Insurers said that ‘we would not support the indiscriminate import of overseas requirements’. It raised particular objection to any move towards a Sarbanes-Oxley style framework. It was, however, more receptive to the idea of public statements on effectiveness of controls.

While it understood reservations on the subject, it believed that ‘the opportunity for engagement with shareholders – which should follow from discursive discussion of risks and how they are managed – should itself contribute to good management of risk and improved confidence’.

Related Articles

Is predictive analytics the end of the annual audit?

Audit Is predictive analytics the end of the annual audit?

3d Martin Herron, MHA MacIntyre Hudson
Auditors ‘in the dock’ over Carillion as report calls for Big Four break-up

Audit Auditors ‘in the dock’ over Carillion as report calls for Big Four break-up

1w Emma Smith, Managing Editor
PCAOB sanctions former Deloitte Turkey CEOs over altered documents

Audit PCAOB sanctions former Deloitte Turkey CEOs over altered documents

2w Alia Shoaib, Reporter
KPMG South Africa to review past audit work amid fresh scandal

Audit KPMG South Africa to review past audit work amid fresh scandal

1m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
FRC introduces £10m sanctions for Big Four firms

Audit FRC introduces £10m sanctions for Big Four firms

1m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Ukraine’s PrivatBank files $3bn claim against PwC

Audit Ukraine’s PrivatBank files $3bn claim against PwC

2m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Grant Thornton to exit FTSE 350 audit market, citing Big Four dominance

Audit Grant Thornton to exit FTSE 350 audit market, citing Big Four dominance

2m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Big Four dominate FTSE 250 audit market in Q1 rankings

Audit Big Four dominate FTSE 250 audit market in Q1 rankings

3m Alia Shoaib, Reporter