E&Y hit with £300k negligence claim

E&Y hit with £300k negligence claim

Ernst & Young is facing a £300,000 legal battle after being accused of professional negligence by a procurement group

EuroSourceLine, which provides supplies to car parts maker AervinMeritor,
accuses the firm of breach of contract and negligence, and is demanding damages.

In a writ lodged at the High Court, the company says it discovered
‘anomalies’ in its accounts for 2002 and 2003, and had to call in auditors
Friend to provide revised accounts.

The alleged errors include stock cut-off errors totalling £319,535, which had
not been identified, cash at the bank being understated by £612,917, and
creditors understated by £529,840. Turnover was overstated by £197,448, and the
cost of sales overstated by £172,689, according to a High Court writ.

The firm produced incorrect figures for profit and a profit of £70,281 was
shown as transferred to reserves, but the true position was a loss of £236,571,
the writ says.

EuroSourceLine says Ernst & Young inappropriately addressed some
disclosure and presentational matters and a significant number of bank
reconciliation and posting errors were shown in records, which would have
impacted on its profit and loss account and closing balance sheet.

EuroSourceLine says the problems cost the company more than £74,000 in time
and expenses and £157,460 for the work of Friend. It also claims that its credit
rating was impaired and HBOS reduced its borrowings and increased charges. It
was forced to find alternative funding, which cost an extra £47,185.

E&Y said: ‘This claim is without merit and we will be contesting it
vigorously.’

Related Articles

What are the implications of Global Corporate v Hale for director salaries?

Corporate Finance What are the implications of Global Corporate v Hale for director salaries?

2m Chris Horner
Why accountants are the trusted advisor for funding

Corporate Finance Why accountants are the trusted advisor for funding

2m Dominic Buch
Autumn Statement: tax gap under further attack

Corporate Finance Autumn Statement: tax gap under further attack

6m Stephanie Wix, Writer
Finance director of CMS on mergers, technology and challenges ahead

Corporate Finance Finance director of CMS on mergers, technology and challenges ahead

8m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
SMEs at risk of getting burnt by interest rate rises – why accountants should take note

Corporate Finance SMEs at risk of getting burnt by interest rate rises – why accountants should take note

10m Marc Bajer, CEO, Hadrian's Wall Capital
Grant Thornton recruits new corporate finance partner

Accounting Firms Grant Thornton recruits new corporate finance partner

2y Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Total fraud value at £2bn five-year high, finds BDO

Accounting Firms Total fraud value at £2bn five-year high, finds BDO

2y Stephanie Wix, Writer
MHA MacIntyre Hudson appoints corporate finance director

Accounting Firms MHA MacIntyre Hudson appoints corporate finance director

2y Stephanie Wix, Writer