TechnologyReview lame hacker law, says business

Review lame hacker law, says business

Only 15 hackers were jailed for breaking the Computer Misuse Act in 2001, the government has revealed.

Link: Read our hacking special report

This brings the total number of custodial sentences handed out to hackers to just 22 since 1999. Of those jailed in 2001, eight went to jail just for hacking – the others had also committed other crimes.

Industry bodies have expressed concern about the number of hackers successfully prosecuted and jailed, some going as far as calling for the 1990 Computer Misuse Act to be reviewed.

David Roberts, chief executive of the Corportate IT Forum Tif, said: ‘To me this doesn’t seem a fair reflection of the significant concerns as expressed by large corporates. If this number of prosecutions actually reflected the total amount of activity, then you would not see large organisations spending large sums of money on their electronic security.’

But he said that some serious crimes conducted by computer criminals might be prosecuted under other legislation involving fraud or other crimes.

According to the latest available figures from the Home Office, in 2001 there were 25 prosecutions where breaking the Computer Misuse Act of 1990 was the principle offence. In 58 other cases, offences under the Act formed a lesser part of the prosecution.

Where hacking was the principal offence, 21 of the 25 defendants were found guilty, with just eight being handed jail terms. Of the rest, two received absolute or conditional discharges, four were fined and 15 given community service orders.

When cases where hacking was not the principal offence were included, 15 were sent to prison, 29 were given community service, 15 jailed, four given absolute or conditional discharges and ten dealt with ‘in other ways’.

Philip Virgo, stategic advisor to IT professional body IMIS, said: ‘It is quite clear that the time has come to review the working of the Act. We do need to take a look at it, especially in the context of European plans to harmonise laws.’

Virgo said there was still some uncertainty about exactly what the law covered as well, but he added he was pleased that at least some offenders were being prosecuted under the Act: ‘But it is good to know it has been used and used effectively for those who thought it hadn’t been used at all.’

In 1999 and 2000 there were only 33 prosecutions for offences under the Computer Misuse Act. Offenders received sentences in only 26 cases, of which five received community service and one a suspended sentence. Seven were given custodial sentences, and seven were fined.

Many companies fail to report offences. Last month the head of the National Hi-Tech Crime Unit estimated that two-thirds of companies prefered to try and resolve problems in-house.

Related Articles

HMRC outlines points-based penalty model for MTD

MTD HMRC outlines points-based penalty model for MTD

3d Alia Shoaib, Reporter
GDPR: How legitimate are your legitimate interests?

Regulation GDPR: How legitimate are your legitimate interests?

1w Ian Singer, PKF Littlejohn
Viewpoint: Making Tax Digital is not all doom and gloom

Making Tax Digital Viewpoint: Making Tax Digital is not all doom and gloom

1w Brian Palmer, AAT
Treasury cracks down on Bitcoin amid tax evasion concerns

Regulation Treasury cracks down on Bitcoin amid tax evasion concerns

2w Alia Shoaib, Reporter
AVADO wins award for online ACCA courses

Career AVADO wins award for online ACCA courses

2w Alia Shoaib, Reporter
The role of the accountant as productivity and technology leader

Technology The role of the accountant as productivity and technology leader

2w Receipt Bank | Sponsored
Accountancy in the digital age: Flexibility, agility, efficiency

Accounting Software Accountancy in the digital age: Flexibility, agility, efficiency

3w Pegasus Software | Sponsored
How to get your clients ready for the cloud

Cloud How to get your clients ready for the cloud

3w Sage | Sponsored