TaxAdministrationHMRC faces wall of silence from banks over offshore accounts

HMRC faces wall of silence from banks over offshore accounts

Banks resisting HMRC's demands for information on overseas accounts

The banks are revolting. For once, this is not criticism aimed at risky
off-balance sheet accounting or bonuses. It actually refers to some of the 308
institutions that advisers say are resisting demands for overseas accounts
information from the taxman.

But how far back will this put HMRC’s efforts if it has to trawl through a
backlog of appeals to these so-called Schedule 36 Notices, which advisers say
banks are seriously considering?

The only grounds for appeal for banks is that the taxman’s request was
“unduly onerous” for them to comply with.

John Cassidy, tax investigations partner at PKF, said: “In the vast majority
of cases the unduly onerous defence is not going to work”, but banks were still
mindful of their obligations to clients. Although most banks would not appeal,
he surmised, the challenges that were lodged would still be a headache for HMRC.

“It certainly won’t be a migraine, but it will be a minor headache that’s
going to need an aspirin or two. Whether they appeal or not, banks have a duty
of client confidentiality in addition to complying with the notices. They
shouldn’t just accept it willy-nilly,” he added.

But they face a torrid time. “[Banks] have got vast amounts of money here, or
in the Channel Islands or maybe in their home country, on behalf of UK
residents,” HMRC’s permanent secretary Dave Hartnett has said.

“Certainly some parties are looking to take this forward to appeal. This
issue is really going to run for some time,” said Sue Holmes, head of tax
investigations at Smith & Williamson. “There is a huge amount of confusion
among the banks. They want to help HMRC in any way they can, but the banks also
have to balance this aim with maintaining client confidentiality.”

The tax notices are part of HMRC’s move to expose tax avoiders who have
salted away undeclared income in tax havens, and it has demanded the banks open
up client lists.

Holmes said the generic nature of the notices, which have been sent out in
boilerplate form to all of the 308 banks, had also stumped the banks. She
flagged up a potential issue around its request for account information not
specifying whether this meant cash accounts, investment acc-ounts or trustee
accounts ­ or all of the above.

The taxman is making efforts to help banks clarify their positions by rolling
out guidance, but it is staying tight-lipped about the appeals it may have
received. “We won’t comment on whether there have been any appeals,” an HMRC
spokesman said.

IN OUR VIEW

Client confidentiality may go out of the window because of the legal
muscle contained in the Schedule 36 orders. Whatever the burden on banks, HMRC
is looking to nip tax evasion in the bud.

Related Articles

HMRC issues updated Trusts Registration Service guidance

Administration HMRC issues updated Trusts Registration Service guidance

2w Emma Smith, Managing Editor
‘Significant recovery’ for HMRC customer service, claims boss Thompson

Administration ‘Significant recovery’ for HMRC customer service, claims boss Thompson

1y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
HRMC loses £653,000 tax battle following administration error

Administration HRMC loses £653,000 tax battle following administration error

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
Bid to cut VAT bill on wedding venue hire rejected by Tribunal

Administration Bid to cut VAT bill on wedding venue hire rejected by Tribunal

2y Richard Crump, Writer
HMRC high-value tax cases drop 15%

Accounting Firms HMRC high-value tax cases drop 15%

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
Government deliberates secondary adjustment to transfer pricing rules

Administration Government deliberates secondary adjustment to transfer pricing rules

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
HMRC taskforces raise £540m since launch

Administration HMRC taskforces raise £540m since launch

2y Richard Crump, Writer
Government should rethink “digitally distracted” HMRC, ATT urges

Administration Government should rethink “digitally distracted” HMRC, ATT urges

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter