Auditor independence study under fire

The research, undertaken by the International Centre for research in accounting at Lancaster University, suggested auditors have more difficulty in standing up to companies’ ‘aggressive’ financial reporting tactics when their firm also supplies non-audit services to it.Although it does not put Big Five firms totally in the clear, the report said the problem was more marked among small firms.

Jeremy Newman, audit partner at mid-tier firm BDO Stoy Hayward, said: ‘It’s curious. Commercially it’s easier for us to stand up to clients because the impact would be less severe on us.’

Martyn Jones, audit partner at Deloitte & Touche, criticised the researchers’ assumptions.

‘They’re trying to use ‘abnormal and discretionary’ accruals as a proxy for earnings management. But in reality changes in provisions will in the vast majority of cases be proper judgements reflecting circumstances.’

Professor Peter Pope, director of the Lancaster University’s International Centre for Research in Accounting, said: ‘Earnings management occurs and some firms are openly criticised for being aggressive in their recognition of profits.’


Research supports SEC rule change

The Lancaster University Management School online

Related reading