Poor research harming profession says ICAS
Quality not matching quantity of studies being hawked by limelight-seeking accountants, says Isobel Sharp
Quality not matching quantity of studies being hawked by limelight-seeking accountants, says Isobel Sharp
A glut of poor-quality, publicity-seeking research by institutes, firms and
other bodies is harming the reputation of UK accountants.
‘Too many lightweight, piecemeal, poorly researched and inadequately tested
outpourings damage the profession and the public,’ Isobel Sharp, who stands down
as president of ICAS on Friday, said last night.
Speaking at an event celebrating the 20 years of the landmark ICAS report
Making Corporate Reports Valuable, generally considered to be the first thought
leadership initiative by a UK accountancy body, Sharp urged the profession to up
its game.
The Deloitte partner said research should only be undertaken if it would
command respect; serve the public interest; was open, inclusive and accessible;
was well researched and had been ‘tested to destruction’.
Sharp, technical director of the institute when the report was relased,
warned: ‘I’m not convinced current projects would meet that criteria.’
Speaking at the same event, International Accounting Standards Board chairman
Sir David Tweedie, who worked with Sharp on the report, agreed that there was
too much ‘thought leadership’ that was anything but.
‘It’s often a PR job and often as interesting as a book on Antarctic
television personalities of the 18th century,’ he said.
Sharp added: ‘It would be good it we the profession could decide what our big
topics were.’
Others members of the original ICAS committee, including Cairn Energy
chairman Norman Murray and Financial Reporting Council chairman Paul Boyle, also
took part in the debate.
The numbers you crunch tell a story. Your expertis...
16yEmbracing user-friendly AP systems can turn the tide, streamlining workflows, enhancing compliance, and opening doors to early payment discounts. Read...
View articleOrganisations can enhance their financial operations' efficiency, accuracy, and responsiveness by adopting platforms that offer them self-service cust...
View articleIn a world of instant results and automated workloads, the potential for AP to drive insights and transform results is enormous. But, if you’re still ...
View resourceDiscover how AP dashboards can transform your business by enhancing efficiency and accuracy in tracking key metrics, as revealed by the latest insight...
View articleThe ICAEW cited managing insurance costs, firms struggling to obtain coverage, assessing risk-taking capacity, and evolved firm structures as drivers ...
View articleThe IESBA emphasizes the importance of timely and global adoption of their standards. For corporate accountants, this means staying updated with chang...
View articleKPMG's faces record fine for a widespread exam cheating scandal, implicating senior staff and highlighting systemic ethical issues in the professional...
View articlePwC's Australia tax scandal has led to significant changes, including over 300 job cuts and the refusal to share a crucial report with Australian parl...
View articleAccountants and accounting firms play a crucial role in maintaining financial integrity, facing ethical dilemmas and regulatory challenges. Adherence ...
View articleThe creation of an effective sustainability standards infrastructure requires not only high-quality sustainability reporting and assurance standards, ...
View articleChanges will help to make accounting profession more attractive, ICAEW boss says Read More...
View article38% of firms required significant improvements, prompting the council to state Tier 2 and Tier 3 firms must "prioritise audit quality improvements and...
View article