PwC on the attack over Competition Report findings

PwC on the attack over Competition Report findings

Chairman and audit head publicly attack report's claim that PwC merger drove up fees

competition report

PricewaterhouseCoopers rolled out its big guns at a meeting yesterday in a
concerted effort to discredit some findings of a joint government and Financial
Reporting Council report into audit choice.

Kieran Poynter, chairman of the Big four firm, used the public meeting on the
report to cast doubt on some of the results, backed by PwC head of assurance
Glyn Barker.

In particular, both attacked the mathematical model that predicted the firm’s
audit fees rose 12% from one year to the next following the merger of Price
Waterhouse and Coopers & Lybrand in 1998, due to market concentration.

‘If you look at actual audit fees over the last ten years they have not gone
up by 12% compound,’ argued Poynter. ‘It is just not the case, let alone 12%
compound for this one reason. Taking all the reasons together, audit fees
haven’t gone up by that much.’

Barker said that there were a number of industries ‘where concentration has
led to efficiency and price reductions, and while the report may have identified
a correlation between market concentration and fee rises, that doesn’t
necessarily conclusively imply causation.’

Defending the report, Dr Gunnar Niels, director at consulting firm Oxera,
which undertook the research said he could not comment on cause and effect ‘but
that is clearly what the data is telling us’.

Poynter also suggested that the low auditor switching rate by companies may
be associated with a high level of satisfaction, and that where companies have a
lack of choice over auditor it may be because they have made choices over where
to get their non-audit services instead.

He also dismissed the report’s assumption that insurance comprised one of
three components of an audit.

‘None of the Big Four are in the business of providing insurance,’ he said.

Related Articles

FRC reports an “unacceptable deterioration” in KPMG audit quality

Audit FRC reports an “unacceptable deterioration” in KPMG audit quality

24h Alia Shoaib, Reporter
PwC fined a record £10m over BHS audit

Audit PwC fined a record £10m over BHS audit

1w Alia Shoaib, Reporter
KPMG fined £4.5m over Quindell audit misconduct

Audit KPMG fined £4.5m over Quindell audit misconduct

1w Alia Shoaib, Reporter
PwC to net £50m from Carillion insolvency

Accounting Firms PwC to net £50m from Carillion insolvency

2w Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Deloitte faces disciplinary action over Autonomy accounts scandal

Audit Deloitte faces disciplinary action over Autonomy accounts scandal

3w Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Is predictive analytics the end of the annual audit?

Audit Is predictive analytics the end of the annual audit?

4w Martin Herron, MHA MacIntyre Hudson
Auditors ‘in the dock’ over Carillion as report calls for Big Four break-up

Audit Auditors ‘in the dock’ over Carillion as report calls for Big Four break-up

1m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
PCAOB sanctions former Deloitte Turkey CEOs over altered documents

Audit PCAOB sanctions former Deloitte Turkey CEOs over altered documents

1m Alia Shoaib, Reporter