PracticeConsultingDisgust at Smith ruling

Disgust at Smith ruling

FDs and ICA members consider former MP a professional disgrace. Douglas Broom reports.

The English ICA was condemned from all sides this week for its decision not to expel disgraced ex-minister and chartered accountant Tim Smith for misconduct.

Some of the strongest condemnation came from the institute’s own members, scores of whom wrote in or telephoned its Moorgate Place headquarters to complain about the decision to fine Smith #1,000 with #2,150 costs, for taking #18,000 from Harrods owner Mohamed Al Fayed.

In business, a poll of 200 finance directors for Accountancy Age’s ‘The Big Question’ found more than half (52%) thought Smith should have been expelled. Only one in ten of the FDs surveyed agreed with the institute’s decision.

ICA president Chris Laine, who has not commented publicly on the penalty, was said by insiders to have been alarmed at the public impact of the decision but had no powers to overturn it.

The #1,000-fine was the highest penalty short of expulsion available to the committee, because the events took place before 1990 – when its powers to fine were increased.

The reaction of many FDs was summed up by Stuart Chapman of the International Baccalaureate organisation, who said Smith’s conduct had fallen below that required of a professional accountant and he had ‘forfeited the right to membership of the institute.’ Peter Harris of Oxford-based Evenlode Truck Centre was more cynical: ‘He made a good profit on the #18,000 less the fine and costs,’ he said.

Reaction at Westminster was mixed. Former Labour trade spokesman Jim Cousins, MP for Newcastle Central, backed the penalty but complained the institute had taken too long to bring the case to its disciplinary tribunal.

Workington Labour MP Dale Campbell-Savours also supported the institute, arguing that Smith had already paid ‘a very heavy price’ for what he had done. But David Taylor, Labour MP for Leicester North West and a CIPFA accountant, said Smith had been ‘fortunate to escape as lightly as he has.’

Related Articles

5 tips for SMEs to protect cash flow

Accounting Software 5 tips for SMEs to protect cash flow

3m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Tyrie on Finance Bill 2017: ‘Making Tax Policy Better’

Consulting Tyrie on Finance Bill 2017: ‘Making Tax Policy Better’

9m Stephanie Wix, Writer
Managing partner Q&A - the year ahead: Richard Toone, CVR Global

Accounting Firms Managing partner Q&A - the year ahead: Richard Toone, CVR Global

10m Kevin Reed, Writer
Friday Afternoon Live: HMRC complaints rise; Deloitte scoops big audits; and corporate reporting woes

Audit Friday Afternoon Live: HMRC complaints rise; Deloitte scoops big audits; and corporate reporting woes

11m Kevin Reed, Writer
New head of equity capital markets for KPMG

Accounting Firms New head of equity capital markets for KPMG

11m Stephanie Wix, Writer
Deloitte 'self-imposes exile' on government contracts to defuse PM row

Accounting Firms Deloitte 'self-imposes exile' on government contracts to defuse PM row

10m Kevin Reed, Writer
Managing partner Q&A - the year ahead: Julie Adams, Menzies

Accounting Firms Managing partner Q&A - the year ahead: Julie Adams, Menzies

10m Kevin Reed, Writer
Friday Afternoon Live: Deloitte's tech thing; PAC wants HMRC 'contingencies'; and Sports Direct

Business Regulation Friday Afternoon Live: Deloitte's tech thing; PAC wants HMRC 'contingencies'; and Sports Direct

10m Kevin Reed, Writer