PracticeAuditCompetition Commission must roll back on audit rules

Competition Commission must roll back on audit rules

Competition Commission must heed the view of business and adopt FRC approach to audit tendering rules

Competition Commission must roll back on audit rules

THE COMPETITION COMMISSION has been left with much to ponder after receiving formal responses to its proposals to shake up the large-listed audit market.

Industry heavyweights ranging from the likes of HSBC, GlaxoSmithKline and Icap plus the influential Hundred Group of Finance Directors have submitted their views on the watchdog’s plans to increase competition among the Big Four by forcing companies to put their audits out for tender every five years.

The consensus is not good. The measure, so they argue, will not improve competition – in fact it will likely achieve the opposite, while adding to costs, disrupting business and ultimately failing to improve the overall quality of audit.

I previously argued in this blog that the Competition Commission should give the FRC’s own guidelines on ten-year tendering to bed in before increasing the frequency of tenders.

Based on the responses sent to the commission – almost all seem to favour the FRC’s approach – I feel it should refrain from digging its heels in over the issue and listen to the clamour from business.

After all, the tender period is only one element to the proposals and while it grabs all the headlines, there are other remedies – such as the removal of Big Four-only clauses – that will do more to improve competition.

And on the point of improving audit quality, efforts to alter the auditors’ report to include more information – currently being discussed by host of the profession’s regulators – will have a much more lasting effect than anything the Competition Commission has suggested.

Richard Crump is deputy editor of Accountancy Age and Financial Director

Related Articles

The future of the audit industry: From masses of data, to meaning

Audit The future of the audit industry: From masses of data, to meaning

10m Acccountancy Age
Deloitte scoops GSK 'mega audit' from PwC

Audit Deloitte scoops GSK 'mega audit' from PwC

10m Kevin Reed, Writer
Friday Afternoon Live: HMRC complaints rise; Deloitte scoops big audits; and corporate reporting woes

Audit Friday Afternoon Live: HMRC complaints rise; Deloitte scoops big audits; and corporate reporting woes

11m Kevin Reed, Writer
The impact of Brexit on EU audit reform

Audit The impact of Brexit on EU audit reform

1y Richard Crump, Writer
Audit Reform: The Conflict Minefield

Audit Audit Reform: The Conflict Minefield

1y James Roberts, BDO
BDO appointed new auditor of Game Digital as Deloitte ditched

Audit BDO appointed new auditor of Game Digital as Deloitte ditched

12m Stephanie Wix, Writer
BDO's 'agility' makes it well placed to succeed - Eagland

Accounting Firms BDO's 'agility' makes it well placed to succeed - Eagland

1y Kevin Reed, Writer
Friday Afternoon Live: Accountants in government; audit market concentration; Top 40 Networks

Audit Friday Afternoon Live: Accountants in government; audit market concentration; Top 40 Networks

1y Kevin Reed, Writer