RegulationLegalTaking Stock: Unleash the (tax lawyer) hounds

Taking Stock: Unleash the (tax lawyer) hounds

It was accountants versus lawyers at a lively Pinsent Masons debate on legal professional privilege

SITTING THROUGH A DEBATE on legal professional privilege last night, Taking Stock couldn’t help thinking of Mr Burns’ famous line from The Simpsons: “Smithers, unleash the hounds,” while imagining Deloitte tax partner Bill Dodwell emerging from Burns’ mansion grounds bloodied, bruised and suit all a-tatter.

The debate – hosted by Pinsent Masons – began with Bill beset by a ‘murder’ of lawyers [really? Ed] who left the audience in no doubt about whether accountants should be treated in the same way as the legal profession in terms of providing privileged tax advice – the Supreme Court ruled against such a change earlier this year.

“Everyone wants to be a lawyer,” said one lawyer. “We’ve got Ally McBeal…[accountants] have got calculators in top pockets.”

Another QC found himself on the “horns of a dilemma”.

“I really don’t like accountants,” he admitted.

Bill could be forgiven for feeling outnumbered, though he did gamely fight back suggesting that his friends in the legal profession never “addressed the substance” of the issue. And to be fair Bill was hardly alone. He was joined by Mike Truman, editor of Taxation magazine, who capped the night off with a good old fashioned “rant”.

Jesting aside, TS was impressed by the quality of the panel, which included two QCs and Sir Stephen Oliver, while the debate was a nuanced and balanced one. Indeed, Jonathan Fisher QC, who quipped about not liking accountants, turned out to be the profession’s staunchest ally.

“I don’t buy the argument that the whole of the western world will collapse [if legal privilege is extended],” he said. “In the fullness of time the Supreme Court ruling will look out of touch with what is going on in the real world.”

Related Articles

Taking Stock: Harry Potter and the curse of the £1m VAT refund

Legal Taking Stock: Harry Potter and the curse of the £1m VAT refund

1y Taking Stock
Taking Stock: VAT tribunal wraps up Chilango HMRC battle

Administration Taking Stock: VAT tribunal wraps up Chilango HMRC battle

1y Taking Stock
Colin: Panama Papers leak, anonymity regained?

Administration Colin: Panama Papers leak, anonymity regained?

2y Taking Stock
Judges decide on legal privilege

Accounting Standards Judges decide on legal privilege

5y Taking Stock
Colin: Charity case is no defence

Legal Colin: Charity case is no defence

5y Taking Stock
Colin: Rangers' EBT sees red

Corporate Tax Colin: Rangers' EBT sees red

2y Taking Stock
Colin: From Excel to the cells

Legal Colin: From Excel to the cells

3y Taking Stock
Colin: Of LLPs and fish stocks

Accounting Firms Colin: Of LLPs and fish stocks

4y Taking Stock