PracticeAuditBig Four play audit musical chairs

Big Four play audit musical chairs

The Big Four have been swapping audits like kids with marbles, indicating the market may be increasingly dynamic

IS IT ME, or are there signs of change at the top of the audit market? As someone who regularly scans the papers for chopping and changing among the Big Four and their largest competitors, it is relatively rare to see one of the top dogs losing an audit to a peer.

So this morning when I saw Aviva had ditched Ernst & Young for PwC, I counted myself lucky, in the way I imagine a bird enthusiast would do on seeing a flash of unusual plumage in a local park. Imagine my excitement (if possible) at later finding both PwC and Deloitte had lost and won major clients, all in the same day.

Although E&Y shed high profile company Aviva, they managed to wheedle Aegis Group away from Deloitte, which had been the brand management specialist’s auditor since 2004. Deloitte may not have been too cut up, as it nabbed Canadian Pacific’s audit from PwC, while PwC could comfort itself with the star prize of insurance giant Aviva’s audit.

True, these changes still keep high profile audits firmly within the Big Four family, but they may be significant nonetheless. Since the financial crisis turned the spotlight on auditors, investors and shareholders have been uncomfortable with the evidence of auditor-client relations stretching back decades, and audit committees have felt themselves under pressure to justify tendering decisions.

It is hard to say what impact this has had. In some cases, the audit may have been put out to tender, potentially resulting in no change, but at least reminding management that there are other firms in the sea. It could be that such speculative tenders led to surprise bargains from rivals eager to steal a march on one another, pushing companies to switch auditor even if they hadn’t planned to. And in some cases, management may have felt under pressure to make a clean break from the perceived lack of independent audit, actively seeking an alternative to a long-standing audit provider.

It will be interesting to see whether such chopping and changing is well received further down the audit market. Grant Thornton and BDO didn’t get a look in, it’s true, but mid-tier firms must nevertheless be pleased to see dusty old ties being broken and a new measure of dynamism entering the market. With no changes it would be impossible for non-Big Four firms to win larger tenders; perhaps these small shake-ups will reverberate, creating enough momentum to propel firms into the stratosphere of FTSE-listed clientele.

Related Articles

BDO replaces Deloitte as Mitie auditor

Audit BDO replaces Deloitte as Mitie auditor

3m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Deloitte rises in auditor rankings with most FTSE 250 clients

Accounting Firms Deloitte rises in auditor rankings with most FTSE 250 clients

3m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Wetherspoons to replace PwC as auditor

Audit Wetherspoons to replace PwC as auditor

5m Alia Shoaib, Reporter
Audit partner appointed at Grant Thornton in North West

Accounting Firms Audit partner appointed at Grant Thornton in North West

11m Stephanie Wix, Writer
BDO global revenues rise 8% to hit £6bn

Accounting Firms BDO global revenues rise 8% to hit £6bn

1y Stephanie Wix, Writer
BDO appoints audit and restructuring partners

Accounting Firms BDO appoints audit and restructuring partners

1y Stephanie Wix, Writer
Watchdog launches audit investigation into Sports Direct

Accounting Firms Watchdog launches audit investigation into Sports Direct

1y Stephanie Wix, Writer
BDO appointed new auditor of Game Digital as Deloitte ditched

Audit BDO appointed new auditor of Game Digital as Deloitte ditched

1y Stephanie Wix, Writer