BusinessBusiness RecoveryPouring water on phoenix companies?

Pouring water on phoenix companies?

WHEN ED DAVEY, consumer affairs minister, recently announced new proposals to improve the transparency of pre-pack administrations, he must have known that satisfying all interested parties would be a tough call.

A plan to give the outside world three days’ notice that a company was destined for a pre-pack sale has its obvious advantages to unsecured creditors…or does it?

Yes, under the new proposals creditors would be able to apply to the courts to block a sale, they could decide to stop any more supplies from being dispatched, or could aggressively pursue retention of title rights on goods already delivered.

However, all of these could mean that the company fast approaching administration would be severely devalued, to the point where the administrator would have to let the business die. In this type of situation, how would that help unsecured suppliers? They would still be staring at bad debts.

Pre-packs, and their subsequent spawning of “phoenix companies”, have been widely attacked by the credit management profession ever since they were first mooted. I don’t think the credit industry has something against the whole concept per se; what it wants to see stopped is the pre-pack sale back to incompetent or untrustworthy directors.

Some honest hard-working small business people get into difficulty through a bit of bad luck, and even tough old trade creditors have empathy in these situations.
Perhaps an administrator should have to make a professional assessment of the director’s business acumen before contemplating a pre-pack sale back to him? Would this be possible?

Unfortunately, too many pre packs become repeat business casualties within a year or two. That’s why, in my opinion, there are some directors out there that shouldn’t be given such easy second chances to screw up.

Photo by Eric Miller/World Bank

Related Articles

SFP sells off Pixel Projects and saves all staff

Business Recovery SFP sells off Pixel Projects and saves all staff

1y Stephanie Wix, Writer
Administrators from KPMG appointed to City Motor Holdings

Business Recovery Administrators from KPMG appointed to City Motor Holdings

1y Richard Crump, Writer
Begbies Traynor appointed administrators of William Anelay

Accounting Firms Begbies Traynor appointed administrators of William Anelay

1y Richard Crump, Writer
Smith & Williamson appointed administrators of 4Children

Accounting Firms Smith & Williamson appointed administrators of 4Children

1y Richard Crump, Writer
Cowgill Holloway concludes sale of film distributor Metrodome

Accounting Firms Cowgill Holloway concludes sale of film distributor Metrodome

1y Richard Crump, Writer
FRP Advisory sells Harland Machine Systems to Accraply Europe

Accounting Firms FRP Advisory sells Harland Machine Systems to Accraply Europe

1y Richard Crump, Writer
CVR Global sells DMG Steelworkers out of administration in pre-pack deal

Accounting Firms CVR Global sells DMG Steelworkers out of administration in pre-pack deal

1y Richard Crump, Writer
CVR Global administrators appointed at foreign language school

Accounting Firms CVR Global administrators appointed at foreign language school

1y Richard Crump, Writer