TaxCorporate TaxAvoidance isn’t illegal…is it?

Avoidance isn't illegal...is it?

The annual ICAEW Hardman Memeorial Lecture is always good value – last year Dave Hartnett kept calling advisers “alchemists” – experts at turning income into capital – and another David didn’t disappoint this year.

The Exchequer secretary to the Treasury, David Gauke, said he knew advisers often got frustrated with people conflating legitimate tax planning, avoidance and evasion.

However, Gauke then went on to say the government was looking to clamp down on avoidance through the project to modify the tax reliefs system.

Brace yourself for more frustration from advisers then Mr Gauke.

The profession has been banging on forever that “avoidance” isn’t illegal.

He did qualify his statement by saying it’s the instances where reliefs and exemptions are then used in a “highly artificial way,” those are the ones that the government is looking to foil.

“In these instances, people use their resources – and their talents – to twist the law and create results that everyone knows are simply too good to be true,” Gauke said.

But it’s the grey area between skilled advisers making the most of the tax system to arrange clients’ finances efficiently, and anyone deliberately trying to cheat the system, that the term “avoidance” still appears not to adequately distinguish between.

Related Articles

Q&A with the Financial Secretary to the Treasury

Corporate Tax Q&A with the Financial Secretary to the Treasury

6m Emma Smith, Managing Editor
Government looks to close tax loophole on staff benefits

Corporate Tax Government looks to close tax loophole on staff benefits

1y AccountancyAge staff
Budget 2016: Bittersweet budget paves the way for sugar tax

Corporate Tax Budget 2016: Bittersweet budget paves the way for sugar tax

2y Chris Warmoll, Writer
Budget 2016: More HMRC staff and £71m promised to boost digital tax roll-out

Corporate Tax Budget 2016: More HMRC staff and £71m promised to boost digital tax roll-out

2y Chris Warmoll, Writer
Tax breaks needed to save UK oil industry, urges trade body

Corporate Tax Tax breaks needed to save UK oil industry, urges trade body

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
Treasury Select Committee to lead review of UK tax system

Corporate Tax Treasury Select Committee to lead review of UK tax system

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
Knight's suitability as OTS chief questioned by MPs

Corporate Tax Knight's suitability as OTS chief questioned by MPs

2y Fraser Simpson, Reporter
Macpherson to leave Treasury after 10 years in Permanent Secretary role

Corporate Tax Macpherson to leave Treasury after 10 years in Permanent Secretary role

2y Chris Warmoll, Writer