TaxCorporate TaxHMRC creates rod for its own back

HMRC creates rod for its own back

Richard & Judy’s case against the taxman (which I think we can now prefix with the word ‘celebrated’) was covered by almost everyone at the weekend.

There’s one question perhaps that hasn’t entirely been covered, but will be of special relevance to tax professionals.

It’s this: is tax law to be interpreted in a strict and literal manner, or in a purposive manner? Is it the letter of the law that should concern people, or the intention?

The answer, of course, is both, but HM Revenue & Customs is playing a very dangerous game in taking this particular case. Splitting hairs about whether or not Madeley and Finnigan are ‘theatrical artists’ or not leads one to think the letter of the law, rather than its obvious purpose, might be the key thing.

HMRC wouldn’t want tax advisers to think that when pushing avoidance schemes, though, would it?

Related Articles

HMRC hiring spree welcome but won't solve 'customer' service issues alone

Corporate Tax HMRC hiring spree welcome but won't solve 'customer' service issues alone

2y Calum Fuller, Reporter
Tory tax plans ease business’s worries, but personal tax path unclear

Corporate Tax Tory tax plans ease business’s worries, but personal tax path unclear

3y Calum Fuller, Reporter
Ridiculous timeframe given to read and debate the Finance Bill

Corporate Tax Ridiculous timeframe given to read and debate the Finance Bill

3y Calum Fuller, Reporter
HMRC must apply common sense to pay-up first plans

Corporate Tax HMRC must apply common sense to pay-up first plans

3y Calum Fuller, Reporter
Scrapping IR35 all very well – but what else?

Corporate Tax Scrapping IR35 all very well – but what else?

4y Calum Fuller, Reporter
Election concerns likely to colour the Budget

Corporate Tax Election concerns likely to colour the Budget

4y Calum Fuller, Reporter
LLPs guidance delay sign concerns may be heeded

Corporate Tax LLPs guidance delay sign concerns may be heeded

4y Calum Fuller, Reporter
ICAEW takes important educational step in tax debate

Corporate Tax ICAEW takes important educational step in tax debate

4y Calum Fuller, Reporter