Windfall tax is a passport to the political wilderness
The ongoing row over the windfall tax on energy companies seems to miss a fairly fundamental point to me.
There are plenty of good opinion pieces out there criticising the idea. Ross Clark in The Times is worth reading, and if you want a contrary opinion, try, as ever, Richard Murphy, who thinks the tax is necessary and would be a good idea. Chris Dillow offers some intriguing and more positive suggestions for tackling the issue.
Personally, I think the idea is a non-starter because it is politically suicidal.
When New Labour introduced its last windfall tax, it did so for fairly well enumerated reasons, and did so in spite of the fact that it made the party look anti-business, when it was trying to prove the opposite.
At this moment in the electoral cycle, those considerations will come into play in an even more marked fashion.
Britain is about to enter recession, with colossal public debts worked up by a Labour chancellor and now prime minister. Unemployment is threatening to soar, business is suffering, and the tax burden is threatening to rise as the government casts around for solutions to solve its mounting problems.
What worse possible policy could you imagine in that context, than a huge tax grab explicitly designed for redistributive purposes, that will be easily categorised as an anti-business move?
If Brown is forced into it, the comparisons with the demise of previous over-spending and under-performing Labour administrations will be overwhelming. Brown should pursue austerity, and resist this tax move.
More about:
The numbers you crunch tell a story. Your expertis...
16yEmbracing user-friendly AP systems can turn the tide, streamlining workflows, enhancing compliance, and opening doors to early payment discounts. Read...
View articleOrganisations can enhance their financial operations' efficiency, accuracy, and responsiveness by adopting platforms that offer them self-service cust...
View articleIn a world of instant results and automated workloads, the potential for AP to drive insights and transform results is enormous. But, if you’re still ...
View resourceDiscover how AP dashboards can transform your business by enhancing efficiency and accuracy in tracking key metrics, as revealed by the latest insight...
View articleUp to a third of calls to HMRC go unanswered in some months, but its pledge of £45m of investment in its 'customer' service will go a small way to imp...
View articleThe Conservatives' pro-business platform carried the party through the election, but its personal tax policy continues to be vaguer, writes Calum Full...
View articleThe bizarre practice of waving the Finance Bill is counter-productive and has to stop, writes Calum Fuller Read More...
View articleFor those who espouse the morals of paying tax, HMRC's latest strategy doesn't quite sit right Read More...
View articleIR35 has proven ineffective, but 'what are the alternatives?' asks Calum Fuller Read More...
View articleDespite the tendency for pre-election Budgets to be dull, George Osborne may still spring a surprise or two next week Read More...
View articleLLP guidance still not published, with professions on tenterhooks Read More...
View articleEnsuring the right information reaches the public is one of tax's biggest challenges, writes Calum Fuller Read More...
View article